Vercruysse Herman, Backer Tom de, Mommaerts Maurice Y
Dienst Mond-, Kaak- en Aangezichtschirurgie (Head: Maurice Y. Mommaerts), European Face Center, Universitair Ziekenhuis Brussel, Laarbeeklaan 101, 1090 Brussels, Belgium.
Dienst Mond-, Kaak- en Aangezichtschirurgie (Head: Herman Van den Eynde), OLV Ziekenhuis, Aalst, Belgium.
J Craniomaxillofac Surg. 2014 Jul;42(5):377-86. doi: 10.1016/j.jcms.2014.01.005. Epub 2014 Jan 23.
There is currently no gold standard for the treatment of Stage III bisphosphonate-related osteonecrosis of the jaw (BRONJ). The question remains whether osseous reconstruction can offer an additional gain in outcome given the theoretical risk of non-union at the resection margins and recurrence in the osseous free flap. The objective was to conduct a systematic review of articles describing outcomes of osseous microsurgical reconstruction in cases of BRONJ with a minimum follow-up of 12 months, and to present the long-term outcomes of a new case series of three patients.
A multi-database QUORUM-based single-reviewer systematic review identified eight papers that fulfilled the selection criteria. There are only case series and case reports available (Level 4 of the Oxford Evidence-based medicine scale). A total of 31 patients were analysed including the cases described in this article.
The limited overall rate of non-union at the resection margins and the 6.5% recurrence rate of BRONJ in the transplant counters the theoretical objections and advocates for considering osseous free flap reconstruction in the treatment of refractory BRONJ Stage III lesions. However, additional data derived from larger case series or case-control studies are imperative to support this hypothesis.
目前,III期双膦酸盐相关颌骨骨坏死(BRONJ)的治疗尚无金标准。鉴于骨切除边缘骨不连及游离骨瓣复发的理论风险,骨重建能否带来额外的疗效改善仍是个问题。目的是对描述BRONJ病例骨显微外科重建结果且随访至少12个月的文章进行系统综述,并呈现3例新病例系列的长期结果。
基于多数据库的单 reviewer 系统综述,采用QUORUM方法,确定了8篇符合选择标准的论文。仅有病例系列和病例报告(牛津循证医学量表4级)。共分析了31例患者,包括本文所述病例。
骨切除边缘骨不连的总体发生率有限,移植中BRONJ的复发率为6.5%,这反驳了理论上的反对意见,并主张在治疗难治性III期BRONJ病变时考虑游离骨瓣重建。然而,需要来自更大病例系列或病例对照研究的更多数据来支持这一假设。