Plante Elena, Ogilvie Trianna, Vance Rebecca, Aguilar Jessica M, Dailey Natalie S, Meyers Christina, Lieser Anne Marie, Burton Rebecca
Am J Speech Lang Pathol. 2014 Nov;23(4):530-45. doi: 10.1044/2014_AJSLP-13-0038.
Artificial language learning studies have demonstrated that learners exposed to many different nonword combinations representing a grammatical form demonstrate rapid learning of that form without explicit instruction. However, learners presented with few exemplars, even when they are repeated frequently, fail to learn the underlying grammar. This study translated this experimental finding in a therapeutic context.
Eighteen preschool children with language impairment received conversational recast treatment for morpheme errors. Over a 6-week period, half heard 12 unique verbs twice each during recasts (low-variability condition), and half heard 24 unique verbs (high-variability condition). Children's use of trained and untrained morphemes on generalization probes as well as spontaneous use of trained morphemes was tracked throughout treatment.
The high-variability condition only produced significant change in children's use of trained morphemes, but not untrained morphemes. Data from individual children confirmed that more children in the high- than the low-variability condition showed a strong treatment effect. Children in the high-variability condition also produced significantly more unique utterances containing their trained morpheme than children in the low-variability condition.
The results support the use of highly variable input in a therapeutic context to facilitate grammatical morpheme learning.
人工语言学习研究表明,接触到许多代表一种语法形式的不同非词组合的学习者,在没有明确指导的情况下能快速学会该形式。然而,即使很少的示例被频繁重复呈现给学习者,他们也无法学会其背后的语法。本研究在治疗背景下转化了这一实验结果。
18名有语言障碍的学龄前儿童接受了针对语素错误的对话重铸治疗。在6周的时间里,一半儿童在重铸过程中每个动词听两遍,共听到12个不同的动词(低变异性条件),另一半儿童听到24个不同的动词(高变异性条件)。在整个治疗过程中,追踪儿童在泛化测试中对已训练和未训练语素的使用情况,以及对已训练语素的自发使用情况。
高变异性条件仅在儿童对已训练语素的使用上产生了显著变化,而对未训练语素没有产生显著变化。来自个体儿童的数据证实,高变异性条件下比低变异性条件下有更多儿童显示出强烈的治疗效果。高变异性条件下的儿童比低变异性条件下的儿童产生了显著更多包含其已训练语素的独特话语。
结果支持在治疗背景下使用高度可变的输入来促进语法语素的学习。