National Cancer Institute, 9609 Medical Center Dr., Room 4E446, Bethesda, MD 20892. E-mail:
Prev Chronic Dis. 2014 Apr 24;11:E68. doi: 10.5888/pcd11.130280.
Translating government-funded cancer research into clinical practice can be accomplished via virtual communities of practice that include key players in the process: researchers, health care practitioners, and intermediaries. This study, conducted from November 2012 through January 2013, examined issues that key stakeholders believed should be addressed to create and sustain government-sponsored virtual communities of practice to integrate cancer control research, practice, and policy and demonstrates how concept mapping can be used to present relevant issues.
Key stakeholders brainstormed statements describing what is needed to create and sustain virtual communities of practice for moving cancer control research into practice. Participants rated them on importance and feasibility, selected most relevant statements, and sorted them into clusters. I used concept mapping to examine the issues identified and multidimensional scaling analyses to create a 2-dimensional conceptual map of the statement clusters.
Participants selected 70 statements and sorted them into 9 major clusters related to creating and sustaining virtual communities of practice: 1) standardization of best practices, 2) external validity, 3) funding and resources, 4) social learning and collaboration, 5) cooperation, 6) partnerships, 7) inclusiveness, 8) social determinants and cultural competency, and 9) preparing the environment. Researchers, health care practitioners, and intermediaries were in relative agreement regarding issues of importance for creating these communities.
Virtual communities of practice can be created to address the needs of researchers, health care practitioners, and intermediaries by using input from these key stakeholders. Increasing linkages between these subgroups can improve the translation of research into practice. Similarities and differences between groups can provide valuable information to assist the government in developing virtual communities of practice.
将政府资助的癌症研究转化为临床实践,可以通过包括研究人员、医疗保健从业者和中介机构在内的实践虚拟社区来实现。本研究于 2012 年 11 月至 2013 年 1 月进行,研究了关键利益相关者认为应解决的问题,以创建和维持政府资助的虚拟实践社区,以整合癌症控制研究、实践和政策,并展示了如何使用概念映射来呈现相关问题。
关键利益相关者集思广益,提出了描述创建和维持虚拟实践社区以将癌症控制研究转化为实践所需的条件的陈述。参与者对其重要性和可行性进行了评分,选择了最相关的陈述,并将其分类为集群。我使用概念映射来检查确定的问题,并使用多维尺度分析创建陈述集群的二维概念图。
参与者选择了 70 个陈述,并将其分为 9 个主要集群,涉及创建和维持虚拟实践社区:1)最佳实践的标准化,2)外部有效性,3)资金和资源,4)社会学习和协作,5)合作,6)伙伴关系,7)包容性,8)社会决定因素和文化能力,以及 9)准备环境。研究人员、医疗保健从业者和中介机构在创建这些社区的重要问题上相对一致。
可以通过使用这些关键利益相关者的投入来创建实践虚拟社区,以满足研究人员、医疗保健从业者和中介机构的需求。增加这些亚组之间的联系可以提高研究向实践的转化。群体之间的相似性和差异可以提供有价值的信息,以帮助政府开发虚拟社区。