Kopp M S
Department of Psychiatry, Semmelweis Medical School, Budapest, Hungary.
Psychother Psychosom. 1989;52(1-3):74-9. doi: 10.1159/000288302.
87 patients with panic syndrome or agoraphobia with panic were compared with 28 generalized anxiety patients and 29 controls. Psychophysiological measures included rating scales, autonomic responses patterns, auditory thresholds and vigilance characteristics. In panic patients the state anxiety and the blood and injury phobia were significantly higher than in generalized anxiety patients. The generalized anxiety group could be characterized by high trait anxiety, suicidal ideation and lower capacity for sustained attention. Phasic electrodermal response amplitudes to the first verbal stimulus were significantly higher on the nondominant hands of the panic patients and on the dominant hands of the generalized anxiety patients. At 8,000 Hz panic and generalized anxiety patients showed opposite asymmetries of auditory thresholds with a left ear advantage for generalized anxiety patients and a right ear advantage for panic patients. These results suggest a relative left-hemispheric activation dominance in panic patients and a relative right-hemispheric dominance in generalized anxiety patients. The most consistent background factors in both anxiety groups were the highly significantly increased dysfunctional attitudes, first of all the high level of external control compared to controls.
87名患有惊恐综合征或伴有惊恐发作的广场恐惧症患者与28名广泛性焦虑症患者及29名对照组进行了比较。心理生理测量包括评定量表、自主反应模式、听觉阈值和警觉特征。惊恐患者的状态焦虑以及对血液和受伤的恐惧显著高于广泛性焦虑患者。广泛性焦虑组的特征为特质焦虑高、有自杀观念以及持续注意力的能力较低。对第一个言语刺激的阶段性皮肤电反应幅度,在惊恐患者的非优势手以及广泛性焦虑患者的优势手上显著更高。在8000赫兹时,惊恐患者和广泛性焦虑患者表现出相反的听觉阈值不对称性,广泛性焦虑患者左耳优势,惊恐患者右耳优势。这些结果表明,惊恐患者相对存在左半球激活优势,而广泛性焦虑患者相对存在右半球优势。两个焦虑组最一致的背景因素是功能失调性态度高度显著增加,首先是与对照组相比外部控制水平较高。