Lee Seung Yeol, Jeong Jiwon, Lee Kyungho, Chung Chin Youb, Lee Kyoung Min, Kwon Soon-Sun, Choi Young, Kim Tae Gyun, Lee Jeong Ik, Lee Jehee, Park Moon Seok
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Seoul National University Bundang Hospital, Kyungki, Korea.
BMC Musculoskelet Disord. 2014 May 24;15:175. doi: 10.1186/1471-2474-15-175.
Codman's paradox reveals a misunderstanding of geometry in orthopedic practice. Physicians often encounter situations that cannot be understood intuitively during orthopedic interventions such as corrective osteotomy. Occasionally, unexpected angular or rotational deformity occurs during surgery.This study aimed to draw the attention of orthopedic surgeons toward the concepts of orientation and rotation and demonstrate the potential for unexpected deformity after orthopedic interventions. This study focused on three situations: shoulder arthrodesis, femoral varization derotational osteotomy, and femoral derotation osteotomy.
First, a shoulder model was generated to calculate unexpected rotational deformity to demonstrate Codman's paradox. Second, femoral varization derotational osteotomy was simulated using a cylinder model. Third, a reconstructed femoral model was used to calculate unexpected angular or rotational deformity during femoral derotation osteotomy.
Unexpected external rotation was found after forward elevation and abduction of the shoulder joint. In the varization and derotation model, closed-wedge osteotomy and additional derotation resulted in an unexpected extension and valgus deformity, namely, under-correction of coxa valga. After femoral derotational osteotomy, varization and extension of the distal fragment occurred, although the extension was negligible.
Surgeons should be aware of unexpected angular deformity after surgical procedure involving bony areas. The degree of deformity differs depending on the context of the surgical procedure. However, this study reveals that notable deformities can be expected during orthopedic procedures such as femoral varization derotational osteotomy.
Codman 悖论揭示了骨科实践中对几何学的误解。骨科医生在诸如矫正截骨术等骨科干预过程中经常会遇到无法凭直觉理解的情况。手术中偶尔会出现意外的角度或旋转畸形。本研究旨在引起骨科医生对方向和旋转概念的关注,并证明骨科干预后出现意外畸形的可能性。本研究聚焦于三种情况:肩关节融合术、股骨内翻旋转截骨术和股骨旋转截骨术。
首先,生成一个肩部模型以计算意外的旋转畸形,从而证明 Codman 悖论。其次,使用圆柱模型模拟股骨内翻旋转截骨术。第三,使用重建的股骨模型计算股骨旋转截骨术中意外的角度或旋转畸形。
肩关节前屈上举和外展后发现意外的外旋。在股骨内翻和旋转模型中,闭合楔形截骨术和额外的旋转导致意外的伸直和外翻畸形,即髋外翻矫正不足。股骨旋转截骨术后,远端骨块出现内翻和伸直,尽管伸直程度可忽略不计。
外科医生应意识到涉及骨区域的手术后可能出现意外的角度畸形。畸形程度因手术情况而异。然而,本研究表明,在诸如股骨内翻旋转截骨术等骨科手术过程中可能会出现明显的畸形。