Helton Kathleen J, Adams Robert J, Kesler Karen L, Lockhart Alex, Aygun Banu, Driscoll Catherine, Heeney Matthew M, Jackson Sherron M, Krishnamurti Lakshmanan, Miller Scott T, Sarnaik Sharada A, Schultz William H, Ware Russell E
St. Jude Children's Research Hospital, Memphis, TN;
Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston, SC;
Blood. 2014 Aug 7;124(6):891-8. doi: 10.1182/blood-2013-12-545186. Epub 2014 Jun 9.
The Stroke With Transfusions Changing to Hydroxyurea (SWiTCH) trial compared standard (transfusions/chelation) to alternative (hydroxyurea/phlebotomy) treatment to prevent recurrent stroke and manage iron overload in children chronically transfused over 7 years before enrollment. Standardized brain magnetic resonance imaging/magnetic resonance angiography (MRA) and transcranial Doppler (TCD) exams were performed at entry and exit, with a central blinded review. A novel MRA vasculopathy grading scale demonstrated frequent severe baseline left/right vessel stenosis (53%/41% ≥Grade 4); 31% had no vessel stenosis on either side. Baseline parenchymal injury was prevalent (85%/79% subcortical, 53%/37% cortical, 50%/35% subcortical and cortical). Most children had low or uninterpretable baseline middle cerebral artery TCD velocities, which were associated with worse stenoses (incidence risk ratio [IRR] = 5.1, P ≤ .0001 and IRR = 4.1, P < .0001) than normal velocities; only 2% to 12% had any conditional/abnormal velocity. Patients with adjudicated stroke (7) and transient ischemic attacks (19 in 11 standard/8 alternative arm subjects) had substantial parenchymal injury/vessel stenosis. At exit, 1 child (alternative arm) had a new silent infarct, and another had worse stenosis. SWiTCH neuroimaging data document severe parenchymal and vascular abnormalities in children with SCA and stroke and support concerns about chronic transfusions lacking effectiveness for preventing progressive cerebrovascular injury. The novel SWiTCH vasculopathy grading scale warrants validation testing and consideration for use in future clinical trials. This trial was registered at www.clinicaltrials.gov as #NCT00122980.
输血转换为羟基脲治疗中风(SWiTCH)试验比较了标准治疗(输血/螯合疗法)与替代治疗(羟基脲/放血疗法),以预防复发性中风并管理在入组前接受超过7年长期输血的儿童的铁过载情况。在入组和退出时进行标准化的脑磁共振成像/磁共振血管造影(MRA)和经颅多普勒(TCD)检查,并进行中心盲法评估。一种新的MRA血管病变分级量表显示,频繁出现严重的基线左右血管狭窄(53%/41%≥4级);31%两侧均无血管狭窄。基线实质损伤很普遍(85%/79%为皮质下,53%/37%为皮质,50%/35%为皮质下和皮质)。大多数儿童的基线大脑中动脉TCD速度较低或无法解读,与正常速度相比,这些速度与更严重的狭窄相关(发病率风险比[IRR]=5.1,P≤0.0001;IRR=4.1,P<0.0001);只有2%至12%有任何条件性/异常速度。经判定有中风的患者(7例)和短暂性脑缺血发作的患者(11例标准治疗组/8例替代治疗组受试者中有19例)有大量实质损伤/血管狭窄。在退出时,1名儿童(替代治疗组)出现新的无症状梗死,另一名儿童的狭窄情况更严重。SWiTCH神经影像学数据记录了患有镰状细胞贫血和中风的儿童存在严重的实质和血管异常,并支持了对慢性输血预防进行性脑血管损伤缺乏有效性的担忧。新的SWiTCH血管病变分级量表值得进行验证测试,并考虑在未来的临床试验中使用。该试验已在www.clinicaltrials.gov上注册,编号为#NCT00122980。