de Andrés-Nogales F, Morell A, Aracil J, Torres C, Oyagüez I, Casado M A
Pharmacoeconomics & Outcomes Research Iberia, Madrid.
Hospital Universitario de La Princesa, Madrid.
Farm Hosp. 2014 May 1;38(3):193-201. doi: 10.7399/fh.2014.38.3.1163.
To estimate treatment costs of blepharospasm, cervical dystonia(CD), upper limb spasticity (ULS) and spasticity in children with cerebral palsy (SCCP) with botulinum neurotoxin type A (BoNT-A) in Spain.
Annual BoNT-A treatment costs were calculated (2013 ex-factory price () applying RDL 8/2010 and RDL 9/2011 deductions), based on initial dose (id), average dose (ad) and maximum dose (md) according to Summary of Product Characteristics of Botox® (100U/50U), Dysport®(500U) and Xeomin® (100U) and considering the use of complete vials.In addition, annual treatment costs were calculated considering the useof vials in more than one patient and also patient population annual treatment costs based on diseases' prevalence.
Annual BoNT-A treatment costs per patient were estimated at between 265 and 2,120 with savings from 10% to 55% accordingto the selected BoNT-A. CD and ULS treatment provided the greatest cost per patient. Botox® provided greater savings in ULS (id/ad), CD(id), and in blepharospasm and SCCP (id/ad/md). Dysport® treatment was less costly in CD (md) and ULS (md), while Xeomin® was in CD(ad). Based on the estimated treated population in Spain, the annual treatment costs ranged from 368,392 to 13,958,836 depending on indication, dose and BoNT-A considered.
The appropriate BoNT-A choice would lead to considerable savings for the National Health System. Botox® would generate lower costs per patient than other BoNT-A products in 9 out of 12 scenarios considered.
估算在西班牙使用A型肉毒杆菌毒素(BoNT-A)治疗眼睑痉挛、颈部肌张力障碍(CD)、上肢痉挛(ULS)以及脑瘫患儿痉挛(SCCP)的治疗成本。
根据保妥适®(100U/50U)、得保松®(500U)和泽明®(100U)的产品特性摘要,基于初始剂量(id)、平均剂量(ad)和最大剂量(md),并考虑整瓶药物的使用情况,计算年度BoNT-A治疗成本(采用2013年出厂价(€),应用RDL 8/2010和RDL 9/2011的扣除标准)。此外,还计算了考虑在多名患者中使用药瓶情况下的年度治疗成本,以及基于疾病患病率的患者群体年度治疗成本。
根据所选的BoNT-A,每位患者的年度BoNT-A治疗成本估计在265€至2120€之间,节省幅度为10%至55%。CD和ULS治疗的每位患者成本最高。保妥适®在ULS(id/ad)、CD(id)以及眼睑痉挛和SCCP(id/ad/md)方面节省幅度更大。得保松®在CD(md)和ULS(md)治疗中成本较低,而泽明®在CD(ad)治疗中成本较低。根据西班牙估计的治疗人群,年度治疗成本根据适应症、剂量和所考虑的BoNT-A不同,在368,392€至13,958,836€之间。
选择合适的BoNT-A将为国家卫生系统带来可观的节省。在所考虑的12种情况中的9种情况下,保妥适®产生的每位患者成本低于其他BoNT-A产品。