Department of Vascular and Endovascular Surgery, University Clinics, University of Cologne, Cologne, Germany.
Section of Vascular Surgery, Department of Surgery, University of Regensburg, Department of Vascular Surgery, Klinikum Nuernberg, Nuremberg, Germany.
Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg. 2014 Sep;48(3):285-91. doi: 10.1016/j.ejvs.2014.05.012. Epub 2014 Jun 22.
Uncomplicated acute type B aortic dissection (AD) treated conservatively has a 10% 30-day mortality and up to 25% need intervention within 4 years. In complicated AD, stent grafts have been encouraging. The aim of the present prospective randomised trial was to compare best medical treatment (BMT) with BMT and Gore TAG stent graft in patients with uncomplicated AD. The primary endpoint was a combination of incomplete/no false lumen thrombosis, aortic dilatation, or aortic rupture at 1 year.
The AD history had to be less than 14 days, and exclusion criteria were rupture, impending rupture, malperfusion. Of the 61 patients randomised, 80% were DeBakey type IIIB.
Thirty-one patients were randomised to the BMT group and 30 to the BMT+TAG group. Mean age was 63 years for both groups. The left subclavian artery was completely covered in 47% and in part in 17% of the cases. During the first 30 days, no deaths occurred in either group, but there were three crossovers from the BMT to the BMT+TAG group, all due to progression of disease within 1 week. There were two withdrawals from the BMT+TAG group. At the 1-year follow up there had been another two failures in the BMT group: one malperfusion and one aneurysm formation (p = .056 for all). One death occurred in the BMT+TAG group. For the overall endpoint BMT+TAG was significantly different from BMT only (p < .001). Incomplete false lumen thrombosis, was found in 13 (43%) of the TAG+BMT group and 30 (97%) of the BMT group (p < .001). The false lumen reduced in size in the BMT+TAG group (p < .001) whereas in the BMT group it increased. The true lumen increased in the BMT+TAG (p < .001) whereas in the BMT group it remained unchanged. The overall transverse diameter was the same at the beginning and after 1 year in the BMT group (42.1 mm), but in the BMT+TAG it decreased (38.8 mm; p = .062).
Uncomplicated AD can be safely treated with the Gore TAG device. Remodelling with thrombosis of the false lumen and reduction of its diameter is induced by the stent graft, but long term results are needed.
保守治疗的单纯性急性 B 型主动脉夹层(AD)的 30 天死亡率为 10%,4 年内需要介入治疗的比例高达 25%。在复杂的 AD 中,支架移植物的效果令人鼓舞。本前瞻性随机试验的目的是比较单纯性 AD 患者的最佳药物治疗(BMT)与 BMT 和戈尔 TAG 支架移植物的疗效。主要终点是 1 年内不完全/无假腔血栓形成、主动脉扩张或主动脉破裂的综合指标。
AD 病史必须少于 14 天,排除标准为破裂、即将破裂、灌注不良。61 例随机患者中,80%为 DeBakey ⅢB 型。
31 例患者被随机分配至 BMT 组,30 例患者被随机分配至 BMT+TAG 组。两组的平均年龄均为 63 岁。左锁骨下动脉完全覆盖的比例为 47%,部分覆盖的比例为 17%。在前 30 天内,两组均无死亡,但有 3 例从 BMT 组交叉至 BMT+TAG 组,均因 1 周内疾病进展所致。BMT+TAG 组有 2 例退出。在 1 年的随访中,BMT 组又出现了 2 例失败:1 例灌注不良,1 例动脉瘤形成(所有比较的 P =.056)。BMT+TAG 组有 1 例死亡。对于总体终点,BMT+TAG 与单纯 BMT 有显著差异(P <.001)。TAG+BMT 组的不完全假腔血栓形成率为 13 例(43%),BMT 组为 30 例(97%)(P <.001)。BMT+TAG 组的假腔缩小(P <.001),而 BMT 组的假腔增大。BMT+TAG 组的真腔增大(P <.001),而 BMT 组的真腔不变。BMT 组在开始和 1 年后的总横径相同(42.1mm),但 BMT+TAG 组的横径减小(38.8mm;P =.062)。
戈尔 TAG 装置可安全治疗单纯性 AD。支架移植物可诱导假腔血栓形成和直径缩小,实现重塑,但需要长期结果。