Yeoh D, Tourret L
Brighton and Sussex University Hospital, Brighton, UK
Brighton and Sussex University Hospital, Brighton, UK.
J Hand Surg Eur Vol. 2015 Jun;40(5):458-68. doi: 10.1177/1753193414539796. Epub 2014 Jun 23.
We reviewed evidence on total wrist replacement from the last 5 years. Eight articles met a minimum set standard. The results of 405 prostheses were available, including seven different manufacturers. The mean follow up was 2.3-7.3 years with an average age of 52-63. Rheumatoid arthritis was the indication in 42% of patients. Motec demonstrated the best post-operative DASH scores. Only Maestro achieved a defined functional range of motion post-operatively. Universal 2 displayed the highest survival rates (100% at 3-5 years), while Elos had the lowest (57% at 5 years). Biaxial had the highest complication rates (68.7%), while Remotion had the lowest (11%). Wrist arthroplasty preserves some range of motion. Functional scores improved and were maintained over the mid- to long-term. Complication rates were higher than wrist fusion, with reports of radiological loosening and osteolysis. The evidence does not support the widespread use of arthroplasty over arthrodesis, and careful patient selection is essential.
我们回顾了过去5年中有关全腕关节置换的证据。8篇文章符合最低设定标准。有405个假体的结果可供参考,涉及7个不同的制造商。平均随访时间为2.3至7.3年,平均年龄为52至63岁。类风湿性关节炎是42%患者的适应症。Motec术后DASH评分最佳。只有Maestro术后达到了明确的功能活动范围。Universal 2显示出最高的生存率(3至5年为100%),而Elos的生存率最低(5年为57%)。双轴假体的并发症发生率最高(68.7%),而Remotion的并发症发生率最低(11%)。腕关节成形术保留了一定的活动范围。功能评分得到改善并在中长期保持。并发症发生率高于腕关节融合术,有放射学松动和骨溶解的报道。证据不支持在关节固定术之上广泛使用关节成形术,谨慎选择患者至关重要。