Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA; Northwestern McGaw Medical Center/The Rehabilitation Institute of Chicago, Chicago, IL.
Pain Physician. 2014 Jul-Aug;17(4):297-304.
In spite of the widespread performance of intra-articular zygapophyseal joint (IAZJ) injections, we know of no systematic analysis to date that examines the risks and types of adverse events when IAZJ injections are performed.
To describe the type, incidence, and factors contributing to adverse events associated with fluoroscopically guided IAZJ injections.
A retrospective, cohort study of English-speaking adults aged 18 - 90 years who underwent fluoroscopically guided IAZJ injections between March 8, 2004, and April 19, 2007. Following IAZJ injections, 3 senior researchers recorded the presence and type of adverse events. The relationship of adverse events with age, gender, fluoroscopy time, vital signs, and trainee presence was analyzed with Fisher's exact or Wilcoxon rank sum 2-sided tests. Frequency of immediate (during or immediately after the procedure) or delayed (within 24 - 72 hours following the procedure) adverse events.
Tertiary, academic, outpatient physical medicine and rehabilitation interventional spine clinic.
One hundred ninety-one patients (111 men) underwent 239 procedures. The mean and standard deviation (SD) of subject age was 56.4 (16.6) years ranging from 20 to 89. The mean and SD of pre-procedure 11-point Visual Analog Pain Scale was 5.5 (2.2) ranging from 0 to 10, and for post-procedure was 2.6 (2.6) ranging from 0 to 10. Trainees were involved in 52.3% of procedures. Reported immediate adverse events were vasovagal reaction (3.8%, n = 9) and steroid clogged needle (0.4%, n = 1). Follow-up data were available for 185/239 procedures (77.4%). There were 35 adverse events reported at mean follow-up interval of 1.8 days, of which the most frequent were injection site soreness (6.0%, n = 11), pain exacerbation (4.3%, n = 8), sleeplessness (2.2%, n = 4), and transient headache (1.6%, n = 3). Patient gender, age, trainee involvement, pre-procedural pain score, systolic or diastolic blood pressure, pulse, hemoglobin saturation as measured by pulse oximetry, volume of corticosteroid injected, and duration of fluoroscopy were not found to have a significant effect on immediate or delayed adverse events.
This study is limited by a 24- to 72-hour follow-up window, which may have also been too small to capture more delayed complications, and a sample size too small to accurately define the incidence of rare complications.
Fluoroscopically guided IAZJ injections have minimal adverse effects. The most common immediate adverse event was vasovagal reaction and most common delayed adverse event was injection site soreness.
尽管关节突关节内注射(IAZJ)在临床上广泛应用,但目前尚无系统分析评估其相关风险和不良事件类型。
描述关节突关节内注射后不良事件的类型、发生率及相关影响因素。
回顾性队列研究,纳入 2004 年 3 月 8 日至 2007 年 4 月 19 日期间行关节突关节内注射的 18-90 岁的英语为母语的成年人。关节突关节内注射后,3 位资深研究员记录不良事件的发生类型和严重程度。采用 Fisher 确切概率法或 Wilcoxon 秩和检验分析不良事件与年龄、性别、透视时间、生命体征和带教医师的关系。记录即刻(操作过程中或操作后即刻)和迟发(操作后 24-72 小时内)不良事件的发生频率。
三级学术型门诊物理医学与康复介入脊柱诊所。
共 191 名患者(111 名男性)接受了 239 次关节突关节内注射。患者的平均年龄(SD)为 56.4(16.6)岁,年龄范围为 20-89 岁。术前 11 分制视觉模拟疼痛量表的平均(SD)评分 5.5(2.2)分,范围为 0-10 分,术后评分 2.6(2.6)分,范围为 0-10 分。52.3%的操作有带教医师参与。即刻报告的不良事件为血管迷走反应(3.8%,9 例)和类固醇药物堵塞针头(0.4%,1 例)。239 次关节突关节内注射中,185 次(77.4%)获得了随访数据。在平均 1.8 天的随访期内,共报告了 35 例不良事件,其中最常见的是注射部位疼痛(6.0%,11 例)、疼痛加重(4.3%,8 例)、失眠(2.2%,4 例)和一过性头痛(1.6%,3 例)。患者性别、年龄、带教医师参与、术前疼痛评分、收缩压或舒张压、脉搏、脉搏血氧饱和度、注射的皮质类固醇剂量和透视时间均与即刻或迟发不良事件无显著相关性。
本研究存在以下局限性:仅随访至 24-72 小时,可能遗漏了更迟发的并发症;样本量小,难以准确确定罕见并发症的发生率。
关节突关节内注射的不良事件较少见,最常见的即刻不良事件为血管迷走反应,最常见的迟发不良事件为注射部位疼痛。