Monaco Anthony P
Clin Transpl. 2013:157-66.
Since the discovery of acquired immunological tolerance, chimerism has always been associated with tolerance. There is, however, a frequent dichotomy between chimerism and tolerance. Many experimental strategies that produce chimerism do not induce tolerance. In addition, some types of chimerism frequently occur after solid organ transplantation, but rarely result in tolerance. In experimental models of transient lymphocyte depletion with antilymphocyte serum, bone marrow cells exhibit a unique ability to induce allograft tolerance that is superior to that of other lymphoid cells. This tolerance can be augmented with standard immunosuppressive agents used in clinical transplantation. There are currently four ongoing clinical trials of tolerance induction to renal allografts that employ various protocols of non-myeloablative conditioning and donor bone marrow infusion. All four trials have been remarkably successful in achieving short- and moderate-term duration tolerance with minimal morbidity and complications. Persistent tolerance (total drug withdrawal) has been achieved in recipients with durable substantial chimerism. Durable tolerance has also been achieved in recipients who have lost chimerism before or after drug withdrawal has been initiated, as well as in recipients in whom only transient (less than three weeks) or no chimerism at all has been achieved. Although chimeric recipients have rejected grafts during drug withdrawal, durable chimerism is thus far the most positive biomarker for likely successful tolerance induction. At present, there is no proof that chimerism causes tolerance per se; the data are also consistent with another etiological mechanism that causes tolerance and thereby permits chimerism to persist. The current experimental protocols for tolerance induction are safe. More transplant programs should consider doing clinical tolerance research.
自从发现获得性免疫耐受以来,嵌合现象一直与耐受相关。然而,嵌合现象与耐受之间常常存在分歧。许多产生嵌合现象的实验策略并不会诱导耐受。此外,某些类型的嵌合现象在实体器官移植后经常出现,但很少导致耐受。在使用抗淋巴细胞血清进行短暂淋巴细胞清除的实验模型中,骨髓细胞表现出一种独特的诱导同种异体移植耐受的能力,优于其他淋巴细胞。这种耐受可以用临床移植中使用的标准免疫抑制剂增强。目前有四项正在进行的诱导肾移植耐受的临床试验,采用了各种非清髓预处理和供体骨髓输注方案。所有四项试验在实现短期和中期耐受方面都非常成功,发病率和并发症极低。在具有持久大量嵌合现象的受者中实现了持续耐受(完全停药)。在停药前或停药后失去嵌合现象的受者中,以及在仅实现短暂(少于三周)嵌合现象或根本没有嵌合现象的受者中,也实现了持久耐受。尽管嵌合受者在停药期间排斥了移植物,但迄今为止,持久嵌合现象是可能成功诱导耐受的最积极的生物标志物。目前,没有证据表明嵌合现象本身会导致耐受;数据也与另一种导致耐受并从而使嵌合现象持续存在的病因机制一致。目前用于诱导耐受的实验方案是安全的。更多的移植项目应该考虑开展临床耐受研究。