Greenberg Joshua I, Alix Kristen, Nehler Mark R, Johnston Robert J, Brantigan Charles O
Section of Vascular Surgery and Endovascular Therapy, University of Colorado, Anschutz Medical Campus, Aurora, Colo.
Section of Vascular Surgery and Endovascular Therapy, University of Colorado, Anschutz Medical Campus, Aurora, Colo.
J Vasc Surg. 2015 Feb;61(2):469-74. doi: 10.1016/j.jvs.2014.07.008. Epub 2014 Aug 15.
Persistent or recurrent symptoms after surgical treatment for neurogenic thoracic outlet syndrome (nTOS) is a problem commonly encountered by high-volume referral centers. The mechanical etiology patterns at reoperation include (1) inadequate previous rib resection, (2) rib regrowth, (3) scar tissue formation, or (4) intact scalene muscle. Reoperative TOS surgery has significant potential morbidity, and therefore, careful patient selection and meticulous planning are required. This study evaluated the utility of multidetector computed tomography (CT) in the differential diagnosis of patients with recurrent or persistent nTOS.
A retrospective record review was performed of a nTOS referral practice of patients treated from 2003 to 2012 to focus on patients reoperated on for recurrent or persistent symptoms. In 2003, a dedicated high-resolution multidetector TOS CT protocol was established to assist in clinical decision making and reoperative planning. A single designated radiologist interpreted all CT images. Imaging, patient clinical characteristics, interventions, and outcomes were reviewed.
The study group included 20 reoperations for recurrent (n = 15) or persistent (n = 5) symptoms. Mean age was 35 years, and 60% of redo cases were in women. Preoperative CT imaging demonstrated the following anatomic patterns: inadequate previous rib resection in 5 (25%), rib regrowth in 5 (25%), scar tissue formation in 10 (50%), and intact scalene muscle in 3 (15%). Operative findings concurred with preoperative imaging in 85% of patients. There were no neurovascular injuries and no major complications. At a mean follow-up of 43 months, improvement or resolution of symptoms was significant in nine patients (45%), moderate in seven (35%), and minimal in four (20%).
Recurrent/persistent nTOS is an often-vexing problem with challenging solutions. These results demonstrate the utility of a TOS protocol CT scan in providing correlative objective findings and in assisting with reoperative planning. Positive radiographic findings that correlate with patient symptoms inform the decision to reoperate.
神经源性胸廓出口综合征(nTOS)手术治疗后出现持续或复发症状是大型转诊中心常见的问题。再次手术时的机械性病因模式包括:(1)既往肋骨切除不充分;(2)肋骨再生;(3)瘢痕组织形成;或(4)斜角肌完整。再次手术治疗胸廓出口综合征具有较高的潜在发病率,因此,需要仔细选择患者并进行精心规划。本研究评估了多排螺旋计算机断层扫描(CT)在复发性或持续性nTOS患者鉴别诊断中的作用。
对2003年至2012年接受治疗的nTOS转诊患者的记录进行回顾性分析,重点关注因复发或持续症状而接受再次手术的患者。2003年,制定了专门的高分辨率多排螺旋胸廓出口综合征CT检查方案,以协助临床决策和再次手术规划。由一名指定的放射科医生解读所有CT图像。对影像学检查、患者临床特征、干预措施和结果进行了回顾。
研究组包括20例因复发(n = 15)或持续(n = 5)症状而进行的再次手术。平均年龄为35岁,再次手术病例中60%为女性。术前CT影像学检查显示以下解剖学模式:既往肋骨切除不充分5例(25%),肋骨再生5例(25%),瘢痕组织形成10例(50%),斜角肌完整3例(15%)。85%的患者手术结果与术前影像学检查结果一致。无神经血管损伤及严重并发症。平均随访43个月时,9例患者(45%)症状改善或缓解,7例(35%)症状中度改善,4例(20%)症状改善不明显。
复发性/持续性nTOS是一个常常令人困扰且解决起来颇具挑战性的问题。这些结果表明胸廓出口综合征CT检查方案在提供相关客观检查结果及协助再次手术规划方面的作用。与患者症状相关的阳性影像学检查结果有助于决定是否再次手术。