Muñoz Karen, Caballero Ana, White Karl
* Department of Communication Disorders & Deaf Education, Utah State University , Logan, Utah , USA.
Int J Audiol. 2014 Dec;53(12):910-4. doi: 10.3109/14992027.2014.943846. Epub 2014 Aug 20.
The purpose of this study was to review the literature on the effectiveness of parent or teacher-completed questionnaires as a tool to screen school-aged children for permanent hearing loss.
A rapid evidence assessment was completed to provide a summary of information published between 1980 and 2013 in English or Spanish. To identify relevant publications, a database search was conducted using nine databases.
Seven studies were identified for inclusion in the review.
Authors of three of the studies recommended use of the questionnaire as a method for screening hearing in school-aged children, and authors of four of the studies did not recommend use of the questionnaire. However, only one of the seven studies provided good evidence that questionnaires are an effective way of identifying hearing loss among children.
There is insufficient evidence that parent or teacher completed questionnaire screening can be reliably used to identify children in need of further hearing assessment. It is clear that more research is needed before concluding that questionnaires are an effective and low-cost tool for use to screen children for permanent hearing loss.
本研究旨在回顾关于家长或教师填写的问卷作为筛查学龄儿童永久性听力损失工具的有效性的文献。
完成了一项快速证据评估,以总结1980年至2013年间以英文或西班牙文发表的信息。为识别相关出版物,使用九个数据库进行了数据库搜索。
确定了七项研究纳入该综述。
三项研究的作者建议使用问卷作为学龄儿童听力筛查的方法,四项研究的作者不建议使用问卷。然而,七项研究中只有一项提供了充分证据表明问卷是识别儿童听力损失的有效方法。
没有足够证据表明家长或教师填写的问卷筛查可可靠用于识别需要进一步听力评估的儿童。显然,在得出问卷是用于筛查儿童永久性听力损失的有效且低成本工具的结论之前,还需要更多研究。