Poon K Y, Li S M, Roper M G, Wong M K M, Wong O, Cheung R T H
Department of Rehabilitation Sciences, Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Hung Hom, Kowloon, Hong Kong, China.
Physiotherapy Department, United Christian Hospital, Kowloon East Cluster, Hospital Authority, Hong Kong, China.
Man Ther. 2015 Feb;20(1):130-3. doi: 10.1016/j.math.2014.07.013. Epub 2014 Aug 6.
Kinesiology tape (KinTape) is a therapeutic tape without much understanding of its mechanism. KinTape claims to increase cutaneous stimulation, which facilitates motor unit firing, and consequently improves functional performance; however these, benefits could be due to placebo effects. This study investigated the true effects of KinTape by a deceptive, randomized, and controlled trial. Thirty healthy participants performed isokinetic testing of three taping conditions: true facilitative KinTape, sham KinTape, and no KinTape. The participants were blindfolded during the evaluation. Under the pretense of applying adhesive muscle sensors, KinTape was applied to their quadriceps in the first two conditions. Normalized peak torque, normalized total work, and time to peak torque were measured at two angular speeds (60°/s and 180°/s) and analyzed with one-way repeated measures ANOVA. Participants were successfully deceived and they were ignorant about KinTape. No significant differences were found between normalized peak torque, normalized total work, and time to peak torque at 60°/s or 180°/s (p = 0.31-0.99) between three taping conditions. The results showed that KinTape did not facilitate muscle performance in generating higher peak torque, yielding a greater total work, or inducing an earlier onset of peak torque. These findings suggest that previously reported muscle facilitatory effects using KinTape may be attributed to placebo effects.
肌内效贴布(Kinesiology tape,KinTape)是一种人们对其作用机制了解不多的治疗用贴布。KinTape宣称可增强皮肤刺激,从而促进运动单位放电,进而改善功能表现;然而,这些益处可能归因于安慰剂效应。本研究通过一项具有欺骗性、随机且对照的试验,探究了KinTape的真实效果。30名健康参与者对三种贴布情况进行了等速测试:真正具有促进作用的KinTape、假KinTape和不使用贴布。在评估过程中,参与者被蒙上眼睛。在前两种情况下,在假装粘贴肌肉传感器的幌子下,将KinTape应用于他们的股四头肌。在两种角速度(60°/秒和180°/秒)下测量归一化峰值扭矩、归一化总功和达到峰值扭矩的时间,并采用单向重复测量方差分析进行分析。参与者被成功欺骗,且对KinTape一无所知。在三种贴布情况下,60°/秒或180°/秒时的归一化峰值扭矩、归一化总功和达到峰值扭矩的时间之间未发现显著差异(p = 0.31 - 0.99)。结果表明,KinTape在产生更高峰值扭矩、产生更大总功或促使更早出现峰值扭矩方面,并未促进肌肉表现。这些发现表明,先前报道的使用KinTape的肌肉促进作用可能归因于安慰剂效应。