Cant Robyn P, Cooper Simon J
School of Nursing and Midwifery, Monash University, 100 Clyde Road, Berwick, Victoria 3806, Australia.
School of Nursing and Midwifery, Monash University, 100 Clyde Road, Berwick, Victoria 3806, Australia; School of Nursing and Midwifery, University of Brighton, UK.
Nurse Educ Today. 2014 Dec;34(12):1435-42. doi: 10.1016/j.nedt.2014.08.001. Epub 2014 Aug 15.
The objective of this article was to review the literature on utilisation and place of Web-based simulation within nursing education. Web-based simulation combines electronic multimedia options with a central video or virtual world to produce interactive learning activities mediated by the learner.
An integrative review.
A search was conducted of healthcare databases between 2000 and 2014 and of Internet sources for hosted simulation programs in nursing. Eighteen primary programs were identified for inclusion.
A strategy for integrative review was adopted in which studies were identified, filtered, classified, analysed and compared.
Of 18 programs, two game-based programs were identified which represented a 'virtual world' in which students could simultaneously or individually immerse themselves in a character role-play. However, most programs (n=10) taught an aspect of procedural patient care using multimedia (e.g. video, audio, graphics, quiz, text, memo). Time-limited sequences, feedback and reflective activities were often incorporated. Other studies (n=8) taught interpersonal communication skills or technical skills for equipment use. Descriptive study outcomes indicated ease of program use, strong satisfaction with learning and appreciation of program accessibility. Additionally, four studies reported significant improvements in knowledge post-intervention.
Web-based simulation is highly acceptable to students and appears to provide learning benefits that align with other simulation approaches and it augments face-to-face teaching. Web-based simulation is likely to have a major place in nursing curricula in the next decade, yet further research is necessary to objectively evaluate learner outcomes and to justify its use.
本文旨在综述护理教育中基于网络的模拟教学的应用情况及地位。基于网络的模拟教学将电子多媒体选项与中央视频或虚拟世界相结合,以产生由学习者介导的交互式学习活动。
综合综述。
对2000年至2014年期间的医疗保健数据库以及护理领域托管模拟程序的互联网资源进行了搜索。确定了18个主要项目纳入研究。
采用综合综述策略,对研究进行识别、筛选、分类、分析和比较。
在18个项目中,识别出两个基于游戏的项目,它们代表了一个“虚拟世界”,学生可以同时或单独沉浸在角色扮演中。然而,大多数项目(n = 10)使用多媒体(如视频、音频、图形、测验、文本、备忘录)教授程序性患者护理的某个方面。通常会纳入限时序列、反馈和反思活动。其他研究(n = 8)教授人际沟通技巧或设备使用的技术技能。描述性研究结果表明项目使用方便,对学习满意度高,且对项目的可及性表示赞赏。此外,四项研究报告干预后知识有显著提高。
基于网络的模拟教学很受学生欢迎,似乎能提供与其他模拟教学方法相一致的学习益处,并且增强了面对面教学。在未来十年,基于网络的模拟教学可能会在护理课程中占据重要地位,但仍需进一步研究以客观评估学习者的学习成果并证明其使用的合理性。