Zumwalt Ann C, Iyer Arjun, Ghebremichael Abenet, Frustace Bruno S, Flannery Sean
Department of Anatomy and Neurobiology, Boston University School of Medicine, Boston, Massachusetts.
Anat Sci Educ. 2015 May-Jun;8(3):230-41. doi: 10.1002/ase.1485. Epub 2014 Aug 22.
Numerous studies have documented that experts exhibit more efficient gaze patterns than those of less experienced individuals. In visual search tasks, experts use fewer, longer fixations to fixate for relatively longer on salient regions of the visual field while less experienced observers spend more time examining nonsalient regions. This study investigates whether changes in gaze patterns reflect learning by students in a medical gross anatomy course. Students were asked to examine photographs of dissections similar to those they experienced in class and to identify the tagged structure in each image. We postulated that, compared to naive behavior (behavior at baseline and when examining unfamiliar content) students would examine familiar content for longer and would direct proportionally more fixation time on cognitively salient regions of the images while using fewer, longer duration fixations. Our students examined familiar images for significantly longer than they did at baseline (P < 0.0001) or for unfamiliar images (P < 0.0001). They also spent significantly longer examining cognitively salient regions of familiar images, as compared to examining those regions at baseline (P < 0.0001) and on unfamiliar images (P < 0.0001). However, these gaze patterns were characterized by more numerous fixations rather than fewer, longer fixations. These individuals are successful learners in a challenging gross anatomy course, but are not experts in anatomy. Therefore we speculate that the gaze pattern they exhibit characterizes an earlier stage of the learning process than has previously been documented in studies of expertise, which have primarily focused on the gaze patterns of true experts.
大量研究表明,与经验较少的个体相比,专家的注视模式更高效。在视觉搜索任务中,专家的注视次数更少、持续时间更长,会在视野的显著区域停留相对较长时间,而经验较少的观察者则会花更多时间检查非显著区域。本研究调查了在医学大体解剖课程中,学生的注视模式变化是否反映了学习情况。要求学生查看与课堂上所经历的类似的解剖照片,并识别每张图像中标记的结构。我们推测,与初始行为(基线时以及检查不熟悉内容时的行为)相比,学生在查看熟悉内容时会花费更长时间,并且会在图像的认知显著区域上按比例分配更多的注视时间,同时注视次数更少、持续时间更长。我们的学生查看熟悉图像的时间明显长于基线时(P < 0.0001)或查看不熟悉图像时(P < 0.0001)。与在基线时(P < 0.0001)和查看不熟悉图像时(P < 0.0001)检查这些区域相比,他们查看熟悉图像的认知显著区域所花费的时间也明显更长。然而,这些注视模式的特点是注视次数更多,而不是更少、持续时间更长。这些学生是具有挑战性的大体解剖课程中的成功学习者,但并非解剖学专家。因此,我们推测他们所表现出的注视模式代表了学习过程中比之前专业技能研究中所记录的更早阶段,之前的研究主要关注的是真正专家的注视模式。