Sowerby Robert J, Gani Johan, Yim Harold, Radomski Sidney B, Catton Charles
Division of Urology, Department of Surgery, Toronto Western Hospital and University of Toronto, Toronto, ON;
Department of Surgery, Austin Health, Victoria, Australia;
Can Urol Assoc J. 2014 Jul;8(7-8):253-8. doi: 10.5489/cuaj.1764.
Choosing adjuvant radiotherapy (RT) or salvage RT after radical prostatectomy (RP) for locally advanced prostate cancer is controversial. Performing RT early after RP may increase the risk of urinary complications compared to RT performed later. We evaluated the urinary complication rates of men treated with surgery followed by early or late RT.
Using a retrospective chart review, we compared rates of urinary incontinence (UI), bladder neck contracture (BNC), or urethral stricture in men with prostate cancer treated with early RT (<6 months after RP) or late RT (≥6 months after RP), 3 years after RT.
In total, 652 patients (between 2000 and 2007) underwent early RT (162, 24.8%) or late RT (490, 75.2%) after RP. The mean time to early RT was 3.6 months (range: 1-5 months) and to late RT was 30.1 months (range: 6-171 months). At 3 years post-RT, UI rates were similar in the early RT and the late RT groups (24.5% vs. 23.3%, respectively, p = 0.79). Prior to RT, 27/652 (4%) patients had a BNC and 11/652 (1.7%) had a urethral stricture, of which only 1 BNC persisted at 3 years post-RT. After RT, 17/652 (2.6%) BNC and 4/652 (0.6%) urethral stricture developed; of these, 6 BNC and 2 urethral strictures persisted at 3 years.
Rates of UI, BNC, and urethral stricture were similar with early and late RT at 3 years post-RT. These findings suggest that the timing of RT after RP does not alter the incidences of these urinary complications and can aid in the decision-making process regarding adjuvant RT versus salvage RT.
对于局部晚期前列腺癌,在根治性前列腺切除术(RP)后选择辅助放疗(RT)还是挽救性放疗存在争议。与延迟进行放疗相比,RP后早期进行放疗可能会增加泌尿系统并发症的风险。我们评估了接受手术治疗后再进行早期或晚期放疗的男性患者的泌尿系统并发症发生率。
通过回顾性病历审查,我们比较了接受早期放疗(RP后<6个月)或晚期放疗(RP后≥6个月)的前列腺癌男性患者放疗3年后尿失禁(UI)、膀胱颈挛缩(BNC)或尿道狭窄的发生率。
总共652例患者(2000年至2007年期间)在RP后接受了早期放疗(162例,24.8%)或晚期放疗(490例,75.2%)。早期放疗的平均时间为3.6个月(范围:1 - 5个月),晚期放疗的平均时间为30.1个月(范围:6 - 171个月)。放疗后3年,早期放疗组和晚期放疗组的UI发生率相似(分别为24.5%和23.3%,p = 0.79)。放疗前,652例患者中有27例(4%)发生BNC,11例(1.7%)发生尿道狭窄,其中放疗后3年只有1例BNC持续存在。放疗后,652例患者中有17例(2.6%)发生BNC,4例(0.6%)发生尿道狭窄;其中,6例BNC和2例尿道狭窄在3年时持续存在。
放疗后3年,早期和晚期放疗的UI、BNC和尿道狭窄发生率相似。这些发现表明,RP后放疗的时机不会改变这些泌尿系统并发症的发生率,有助于辅助放疗与挽救性放疗的决策过程。