Ponzo Michela, Scoppa Vincenzo
Department of Economics and Statistics, University of Naples Federico II, Napoli, Italy, Naples, 80126.
Am J Hum Biol. 2015 Mar-Apr;27(2):164-74. doi: 10.1002/ajhb.22629. Epub 2014 Oct 3.
Several empirical studies point out the relevance of individuals' physical attributes-such as height, weight, beauty-in the labor market. In the same way, physical characteristics may affect lifetime prospects through their impact on the selection of a partner in the marriage market. We analyzed to what extent an individual's height and weight (arguably affecting physical attractiveness, as documented in many studies) are related to lifetime economic outcomes through the marriage market, investigating whether individual height and weight affect the probability of marrying with a "high-quality partner," measuring quality as the partner's educational attainment or as the partner's prospective labor income.
Using a large Italian dataset of married (and cohabiting) couples-the 2005 Italian Health Conditions Survey which provides information on health conditions, individual characteristics, and socioeconomic variables-we estimated separate OLS and Ordered Probit regressions for females and males. Since weight might be endogenously determined, to avoid any estimation bias we also estimated a reduced form equation in which predetermined height affects directly and indirectly (through BMI) physical attractiveness and, as a consequence, the choice of a partner with a given educational attainment.
Our findings suggest that height is a desirable trait in mating selection affecting the partner's socioeconomic characteristics: we found that taller individuals tended to mate with more educated partners, controlling for their own educational level-to take into account the tendency for assortative mating for education-and for other personal traits such as age, geographical residence, city size, and the presence of health problems. On the other hand, we showed that individuals with higher BMI were married to partners with lower levels of education. The results also provide evidence of non-linearity in the relationship between height and educational attainment of the partner. These findings are confirmed for both males and females, but being taller seems to be more relevant for males, while being thinner is more important for females. We have also found that taller and thinner females and males tend to be married with partners earning higher labor incomes. These findings were robust to a number of checks.
Our findings confirm that the physical characteristics that an individual brings to the marriage market influences the outcome in this market: physical attractiveness is exchanged in the marriage market for a higher educational attainment and the ability to earn a higher labor income.
多项实证研究指出了个人身体特征(如身高、体重、外貌)在劳动力市场中的相关性。同样,身体特征可能通过影响婚姻市场中伴侣的选择来影响一生的前景。我们分析了个人的身高和体重(许多研究表明,这可能会影响身体吸引力)在多大程度上通过婚姻市场与一生的经济结果相关,研究个人身高和体重是否会影响与“高质量伴侣”结婚的概率,将伴侣的教育程度或预期劳动收入作为衡量质量的标准。
我们使用意大利一个关于已婚(和同居)夫妇的大型数据集——2005年意大利健康状况调查,该调查提供了有关健康状况、个人特征和社会经济变量的信息——分别对女性和男性进行了OLS回归和有序概率回归估计。由于体重可能是内生决定的,为避免任何估计偏差,我们还估计了一个简化形式的方程,其中预先确定的身高直接和间接(通过BMI)影响身体吸引力,进而影响选择具有特定教育程度的伴侣。
我们的研究结果表明,身高是择偶时一个理想的特征,会影响伴侣的社会经济特征:我们发现,在控制了自身教育水平(以考虑教育方面的 assortative mating 倾向)以及年龄、居住地区、城市规模和健康问题等其他个人特征后,个子较高的人往往会与受教育程度更高的伴侣结婚。另一方面,我们表明,BMI较高的人其伴侣的教育水平较低。研究结果还证明了身高与伴侣教育程度之间的关系存在非线性。这些发现对男性和女性都得到了证实,但个子较高似乎对男性更重要,而身材较瘦对女性更重要。我们还发现,身材较高且较瘦的女性和男性往往与劳动收入较高的伴侣结婚。这些发现经过多次检验后依然稳健。
我们的研究结果证实,个人带入婚姻市场的身体特征会影响该市场的结果:在婚姻市场中,身体吸引力会换来更高的教育程度和更高的劳动收入能力。