Skinner Isabelle, Smith Cathy, Jaffray Linda
1 Nursing and Midwifery, University of Tasmania , Burnie, Tasmania, Australia .
Telemed J E Health. 2014 Nov;20(11):1042-8. doi: 10.1089/tmj.2013.0341. Epub 2014 Oct 7.
Australia has invested heavily to introduce an opt-in personally controlled electronic healthcare record (PCEHR), which incorporates an element of advance care planning (ACP). A further investment of $10 million AUD has been made to increase capability to a fully integrated electronic ACP (eACP). Australia has an aging population, the majority of whom will live, be cared for, and die in the community. ACP in the community setting can support older people to navigate their illness trajectories and health decision-making. Sharing this information with care providers across different healthcare settings is crucial.
The eACPs was conceptualized as a complex social intervention. We conducted a realist review of the literature to explore evidenced-based models of eACP for community-dwelling older people, with chronic, life-limiting illness. A scoping search identified gray literature; a systematic search for empirical evidence was conducted of eight databases, including PubMed and Google Scholar.
Seventeen articles were included, along with 71 other documents. Realist synthesis based on data collected using original abstraction forms was used to develop a model to explain what worked for whom and in what circumstances. Electronic physician reminders and information to patients increased ACP completions. However, there were no precedents for transferring ACPs into a national PCEHR.
We developed a model informed by six core themes from the literature: information sharing, process, initiating conversations, dignity of life (individualized approach), education (individual and community), and collaborative practice (engagement). End-of-life care that is consistent with older people's values and preferences requires robust care processes and efficient information sharing across the healthcare continuum.
澳大利亚投入大量资金引入了一种选择加入的个人控制电子健康记录(PCEHR),其中包含了预先护理计划(ACP)的元素。又投入了1000万澳元,以提高将其升级为完全集成的电子预先护理计划(eACP)的能力。澳大利亚人口老龄化,其中大多数人将在社区中生活、接受护理并离世。社区环境中的预先护理计划可以帮助老年人应对疾病发展轨迹并做出健康决策。与不同医疗环境中的护理提供者共享这些信息至关重要。
电子预先护理计划被视为一种复杂的社会干预措施。我们对文献进行了实证主义综述,以探索针对患有慢性、危及生命疾病的社区老年人的基于证据的电子预先护理计划模型。范围搜索确定了灰色文献;对包括PubMed和谷歌学术在内的八个数据库进行了实证证据的系统搜索。
纳入了17篇文章以及71份其他文件。基于使用原始摘要形式收集的数据进行实证主义综合分析,以开发一个模型,解释在何种情况下对谁有效。电子医生提醒和向患者提供的信息增加了预先护理计划的完成率。然而,将预先护理计划转移到国家个人控制电子健康记录中尚无先例。
我们根据文献中的六个核心主题开发了一个模型:信息共享、流程、发起对话、生命尊严(个性化方法)、教育(个人和社区)以及协作实践(参与)。与老年人的价值观和偏好相一致的临终护理需要强大的护理流程以及整个医疗连续体中的高效信息共享。