Liu Xinchun, Rohrer Wesley, Luo Aijing, Fang Zhou, He TianHua, Xie Wenzhao
Department of Social Medicine & Health Management, School of Public Health, Central South University, Changsha, China; Third Xiangya Hospital of Central South University, Changsha, China.
Graduate School of Public Health, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, USA.
Patient Educ Couns. 2015 Jan;98(1):3-14. doi: 10.1016/j.pec.2014.09.012. Epub 2014 Sep 30.
To conduct a systematic review of studies on doctor-patient communication skills training (CST) for medical students and physicians in mainland China.
We retrieved articles from six electronic databases, and searched additional eligible papers by checking reference lists. Chinese or English-language studies focused on CST and implemented in mainland China were applied to the pre-determined criteria. Articles included were further reviewed under the following categories: participant; training strategy; assessment; and outcome.
20 studies met the inclusion criteria. 90% of the CST improved trainees' communication skills using a strategy which included a didactic component combined with practical rehearsal and feedback. The duration of training varied substantially. A lack of enhancement in empathy, and the use of open-ended questions were reported. 83% of the assessment instruments were self-designed and most lacked reliability and validity testing. Only two of the included studies evaluated patient satisfaction.
The majority of included studies attained statistically significant improvements. Chinese doctors and medical students' communication skills can be enhanced through CST.
Future studies in China should place stronger emphasis on the development of training strategies, validation of the assessment instruments, and evaluation of patient satisfaction affected by CST.
对中国大陆医学生和医生医患沟通技能培训(CST)的研究进行系统评价。
我们从六个电子数据库中检索文章,并通过检查参考文献列表搜索其他符合条件的论文。聚焦于CST并在中国大陆实施的中文或英文研究应用预先确定的标准。纳入的文章进一步按照以下类别进行审查:参与者;培训策略;评估;以及结果。
20项研究符合纳入标准。90%的CST使用了一种包括理论部分与实践演练及反馈相结合的策略来提高受训者的沟通技能。培训时长差异很大。报告称同理心缺乏增强,且开放式问题的使用情况不佳。83%的评估工具是自行设计的,且大多数缺乏信效度测试。纳入的研究中只有两项评估了患者满意度。
大多数纳入研究取得了具有统计学意义的改善。通过CST可以提高中国医生和医学生的沟通技能。
中国未来的研究应更加强调培训策略的开发、评估工具的验证以及对受CST影响的患者满意度的评估。