Modi Neil, Williams Olayinka, Swampillai Andrew J, Waqar Salman, Park Jonathan, Kersey Thomas L, Sleep Tamsin
Department of Ophthalmology, Torbay Hospital, South Devon Foundation NHS Trust , UK .
Med Teach. 2015 Apr;37(4):344-7. doi: 10.3109/0142159X.2014.948827. Epub 2014 Oct 21.
Understanding the learning styles of individual trainees may enable trainers to tailor an educational program and optimise learning. Surgical trainees have previously been shown to demonstrate a tendency towards particular learning styles. We seek to clarify the relationship between learning style and learned surgical performance using a simulator, prior to surgical training.
The Kolb Learning Style Inventory was administered to a group of thirty junior doctors. Participants were then asked to perform a series of tasks using the EyeSi virtual reality cataract surgery simulator (VR Magic, Mannheim, Germany). All completed a standard introductory programme to eliminate learning curve. They then undertook four attempts of level 4 forceps module binocularly. Total score, odometer movement (mm), corneal area injured (mm(2)), lens area injured (mm(2)) and total time taken (seconds) recorded.
Mean age was 31.6 years. No significant correlation was found between any learning style and any variable on the EyeSi cataract surgery simulator.
There is a predominant learning style amongst surgical residents. There is however no demonstrable learning style that results in a better (or worse) performance on the EyeSi surgery simulator and hence in learning and performing cataract surgery.
了解个体学员的学习风格可能使培训师能够量身定制教育计划并优化学习效果。此前已有研究表明外科住院医师倾向于特定的学习风格。我们试图在外科培训之前,使用模拟器阐明学习风格与所学手术操作表现之间的关系。
对一组30名初级医生进行了科尔布学习风格量表测试。然后要求参与者使用EyeSi虚拟现实白内障手术模拟器(德国曼海姆VR Magic公司)执行一系列任务。所有人都完成了标准的入门课程以消除学习曲线影响。然后他们双眼进行了4次4级镊子模块操作。记录总分、里程表移动距离(毫米)、角膜损伤面积(平方毫米)、晶状体损伤面积(平方毫米)以及总用时(秒)。
平均年龄为31.6岁。在EyeSi白内障手术模拟器上,未发现任何学习风格与任何变量之间存在显著相关性。
外科住院医师中存在一种占主导地位的学习风格。然而,在EyeSi手术模拟器上,没有可证明的学习风格会导致更好(或更差)的表现,进而影响白内障手术的学习和操作。