Gordon Michael S, Kinlock Timothy W, Couvillion Kathryn A, Schwartz Robert P, O'Grady Kevin
Friends Research Institute, Baltimore, Maryland, USA, and Department of Criminal Justice, Stevenson University, Stevenson, Maryland, USA.
Friends Research Institute, Baltimore, Maryland, USA, and Division of Criminology, Criminal Justice, and Forensic Studies, University of Baltimore, Baltimore, Maryland, USA.
J Offender Rehabil. 2012 May 1;51(4):222-238. doi: 10.1080/10509674.2011.641075.
The present report is an intent-to-treat analysis involving secondary data drawn from the first randomized clinical trial of prison-initiated methadone in the United States. This study examined predictors of treatment entry and completion in prison. A sample of 211 adult male prerelease inmates with preincarceration heroin dependence were randomly assigned to one of three treatment conditions: counseling only (counseling in prison; n= 70); counseling plus transfer (counseling in prison with transfer to methadone maintenance treatment upon release; n= 70); and counseling plus methadone (methadone maintenance in prison, continued in a community-based methadone maintenance program upon release; n= 71). Entered prison treatment (p <. 01), and completed prison treatment (p< .001) were significantly predicted by the set of 10 explanatory variables and favored the treatment conditions receiving methadone. The present results indicate that individuals who are older in age and have longer prison sentences may have better outcomes than younger individuals with shorter sentences, meaning they are more likely to enter and complete prison-based treatment. Furthermore, implications for the treatment of prisoners with prior heroin dependence and for conducting clinical trials may indicate the importance of examining individual characteristics and the possibility of the examination of patient preference.
本报告是一项意向性分析,涉及从美国首次监狱启动美沙酮随机临床试验中提取的二手数据。本研究调查了监狱中治疗进入和完成的预测因素。对211名有入狱前海洛因依赖的成年男性预释放囚犯样本进行随机分组,分为三种治疗条件之一:仅咨询(监狱内咨询;n = 70);咨询加转介(监狱内咨询并在释放后转至美沙酮维持治疗;n = 70);以及咨询加美沙酮(监狱内美沙酮维持治疗,释放后继续参加社区美沙酮维持治疗项目;n = 71)。10个解释变量显著预测了进入监狱治疗(p <.01)和完成监狱治疗(p <.001),且有利于接受美沙酮的治疗条件。目前的结果表明,年龄较大且刑期较长的个体可能比年龄较小且刑期较短的个体有更好的治疗结果,这意味着他们更有可能进入并完成基于监狱的治疗。此外,对于治疗有海洛因依赖史的囚犯以及开展临床试验的启示可能表明,检查个体特征以及检查患者偏好的可能性具有重要意义。