Esparaz Elizabeth Shanika, Binder S Bruce, Borges Nicole J
Department of Internal Medicine, Wright State University Boonshoft School of Medicine, Dayton, OH, USA.
Office of Academic Affairs, Wright State University Boonshoft School of Medicine, Dayton, OH, USA ; Department of Family Medicine, Wright State University Boonshoft School of Medicine, Dayton, OH, USA.
J Educ Eval Health Prof. 2014 Nov 23;11:29. doi: 10.3352/jeehp.2014.11.29. eCollection 2014.
It is essential that primary care physicians have a solid fund of knowledge of the diagnosis and management of common eye conditions as well as ocular emergencies, as management of these diseases commonly involves appropriate referral to an ophthalmologist. Thus, it is crucial to receive comprehensive clinical knowledge of ophthalmic disease in the primary care setting during medical school. This study investigated how well prepared medical students are to diagnose and manage common ocular conditions. The study used scores from a standardized 12-question quiz administered to fourth-year medical students (N = 97; 88% response rate) and second-year medical students (N = 97; 97% response rate). The quiz comprising diagnosis and referral management questions covered the most frequently tested ophthalmology topics on board exams and assessed students' ability to recognize when referral to an ophthalmologist is appropriate. Fourth-year medical students had quiz scores ranging from 0%-94.5% with an average score of 68.7%. Second-year students had quiz scores ranging from 27.2%-86.4%, with an average score of 63.8%. Passing rate was 70%. Student's t-test showed fourth-year students had a significantly higher quiz average (P = 0.003). In general, both classes performed better on diagnostic questions (fourth-year, 73.7%; second year, 65.8%) rather than on management questions (fourth-year, 64.8%; second year, 61.8%). Both second-year and fourth-year students on average fell short on passing the ophthalmology proficiency quiz, and in general students were more adept at diagnosing rather than managing ocular conditions and emergencies.
基层医疗医生必须具备扎实的常见眼部疾病及眼部紧急情况的诊断和管理知识,因为这些疾病的管理通常涉及适当地转诊至眼科医生处。因此,在医学院期间在基层医疗环境中获得眼科疾病的全面临床知识至关重要。本研究调查了医学生在诊断和管理常见眼部疾病方面的准备情况。该研究使用了对四年级医学生(N = 97;应答率88%)和二年级医学生(N = 97;应答率97%)进行的一项标准化12道题测验的分数。该测验包括诊断和转诊管理问题,涵盖了执业医师考试中最常考查的眼科主题,并评估了学生识别何时适合转诊至眼科医生的能力。四年级医学生的测验分数在0%至94.5%之间,平均分数为68.7%。二年级学生的测验分数在27.2%至86.4%之间,平均分数为63.8%。及格率为70%。学生t检验显示四年级学生的测验平均分显著更高(P = 0.003)。总体而言,两个班级在诊断问题上的表现(四年级为73.7%;二年级为65.8%)优于管理问题(四年级为64.8%;二年级为61.8%)。二年级和四年级学生在眼科能力测验中的平均成绩均未达到及格水平,总体而言,学生更擅长诊断而非管理眼部疾病和紧急情况。