Erasmus Ermin
Health Policy and Systems Division, School of Public Health and Family Medicine, University of Cape Town, Observatory 7925, South Africa
Health Policy Plan. 2014 Dec;29 Suppl 3:iii70-8. doi: 10.1093/heapol/czu112.
This article presents a synthesis of studies that explicitly use the theory of street-level bureaucracy to illuminate health policy implementation in low- and middle-income countries. Street-level bureaucrats are frontline workers in bureaucracies, e.g. nurses, who regularly interact directly with citizens in discharging their policy implementation duties and who have some discretion over which services are offered, how services are offered and the benefits and sanctions allocated to citizens. This synthesis seeks to achieve the dual objectives of, first, reflecting on how street-level bureaucracy theory has been used in the literature and, second, providing an example of the application of the synthesis methodology of meta-ethnography to the health policy analysis literature. The article begins by outlining meta-ethnography and providing more information on the papers on which the synthesis is based. This is followed by a detailed account of how the synthesis was achieved and by an articulation of the synthesis. It then concludes with thoughts and questions on the value and relevance of the synthesis, the experience of conducting the synthesis and the partial way in which street-level bureaucracy theory has been used in the literature examined.
本文对一系列研究进行了综合分析,这些研究明确运用街头官僚理论来阐释低收入和中等收入国家的卫生政策实施情况。街头官僚是官僚机构中的一线工作人员,例如护士,他们在履行政策实施职责时经常直接与公民互动,并且在提供哪些服务、如何提供服务以及分配给公民的福利和制裁方面拥有一定的自由裁量权。这种综合分析旨在实现双重目标,其一,反思街头官僚理论在文献中的运用方式;其二,提供一个将元民族志综合方法应用于卫生政策分析文献的实例。文章开篇概述了元民族志,并提供了更多关于综合分析所基于论文的信息。接下来详细阐述了综合分析是如何完成的以及综合分析的内容。然后文章以对综合分析的价值与相关性、进行综合分析的经验以及在已审查文献中运用街头官僚理论的部分方式的思考与问题作为结尾。