Esseili M A, Kassem I I, Lis J, Sigler V
Ohio Agricultural Research and Development Center, The Ohio State University, OH, USA.
Lorain County General Health District, Elyria, OH, USA.
J Water Health. 2014 Dec;12(4):846-57. doi: 10.2166/wh.2014.034.
We investigated the effectiveness of Escherichia coli community fingerprinting for identifying fecal pollution sources impacting a recreational beach. E. coli in water collected from the beach, nearby creek and storm sewer outfall were enumerated using membrane filtration, while E. coli communities were characterized following polymerase chain reaction analysis and denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE) fingerprinting. Analysis of E. coli densities to determine the contributions of the creek and storm sewer during dry weather was inconclusive. However, DGGE fingerprinting indicated that the creek E. coli communities had a greater impact on the beach community composition (80-95% similarity), than on storm sewer communities (41-64%). Following rainfall events, E. coli communities in the creek were at least 93% similar to those at the beach, while the similarity of the outfall and beach communities varied from 72 to 96%. Furthermore, E. coli communities at the beach were more similar to creek communities than to storm sewer communities after the first 2 h and 48 h following the onset of rainfall, and of comparable similarity following 24 h of rainfall, suggesting transient contributions from the storm sewer. DGGE analysis of E. coli communities provided evidence that the creek was a consistent source of E. coli to the beach, while the storm sewer was a transient source.
我们研究了利用大肠杆菌群落指纹识别影响休闲海滩粪便污染源的有效性。采用膜过滤法对从海滩、附近小溪和雨水排放口收集的水中的大肠杆菌进行计数,同时在聚合酶链反应分析和变性梯度凝胶电泳(DGGE)指纹识别后对大肠杆菌群落进行表征。分析干旱天气期间小溪和雨水排放口对海滩大肠杆菌密度的贡献尚无定论。然而,DGGE指纹识别表明,小溪中的大肠杆菌群落对海滩群落组成的影响更大(相似度为80 - 95%),高于对雨水排放口群落的影响(相似度为41 - 64%)。降雨事件后,小溪中的大肠杆菌群落与海滩中的大肠杆菌群落相似度至少为93%,而排放口和海滩群落的相似度在72%至96%之间变化。此外,降雨开始后的前2小时和48小时,海滩中的大肠杆菌群落与小溪群落的相似度高于与雨水排放口群落的相似度,降雨24小时后相似度相当,这表明雨水排放口有短暂贡献。对大肠杆菌群落的DGGE分析提供了证据,表明小溪是海滩大肠杆菌的持续来源,而雨水排放口是短暂来源。