From the *Anesthesiology Service, VA San Diego Healthcare System, San Diego, California; and †Department of Psychology, UC San Diego, La Jolla, California.
Anesth Analg. 2015 Feb;120(2):449-59. doi: 10.1213/ANE.0000000000000526.
For the dedicated anesthesiologist, a high level of expertise is needed to deliver good care to patients and to provide excellent service to surgeons, anesthesia colleagues, and others. Expertise helps the anesthesiologist recover from difficult situations and generally makes the practice run more effectively. Expertise also contributes to quality of life through higher self-esteem and long-term career satisfaction. We begin by reviewing the attributes that characterize expert performance and discussing how a specific training format, known as deliberate practice, contributes to acquisition and maintenance of expertise. Deliberate practice involves rehearsal of specific tasks to mastery, ideally under the eye of a mentor to provide feedback. This amounts to an orchestrated effort to improve that enables trainees to progress to expert levels of performance. With few exceptions, people who become recognized experts have pursued deliberate practice on the order of 4 hours per day for 10 to 15 years. In contrast, those who practice their profession in a rote manner see their skills plateau well below the level of top performers. Anesthesiology instruction with attending supervision provides all of the necessary components for deliberate practice, and it can be effective in anesthesia. Using deliberate practice in teaching requires organization in selecting training topics, effort in challenging students to excel, and skill in providing feedback. In this article, we discuss how educational programs can implement deliberate practice in anesthesiology training, review resources for instructors, and suggest how anesthesiologists can continue the practice after residency.
对于专注的麻醉医师来说,需要具备高水平的专业知识,才能为患者提供优质的护理,并为外科医生、麻醉科同事和其他人员提供卓越的服务。专业知识有助于麻醉医师从困难的情况中恢复过来,并使实践更有效地进行。专业知识还通过提高自尊心和长期职业满意度来提高生活质量。我们首先回顾了专家表现的特征属性,并讨论了一种特定的培训形式,即刻意练习,如何有助于专业知识的获取和维持。刻意练习包括将特定任务练习到掌握程度,理想情况下在导师的指导下进行,以提供反馈。这相当于一种精心策划的努力,可以使学员进步到专家级别的表现水平。除了少数例外,那些被公认为专家的人每天都会进行大约 4 小时的刻意练习,持续 10 到 15 年。相比之下,那些以常规方式练习的人,他们的技能水平远远低于顶尖选手。在带教监督下进行的麻醉学教学提供了刻意练习所需的所有必要组成部分,并且在麻醉学中非常有效。在教学中使用刻意练习需要在选择培训主题方面进行组织,努力挑战学生以取得卓越成绩,并具备提供反馈的技能。在本文中,我们讨论了教育计划如何在麻醉学培训中实施刻意练习,回顾了教师的资源,并提出了麻醉师在 residency 后如何继续练习的建议。