Chen Jun, Quan Wenting, Cui Tingwei
Water Environ Res. 2015 Jan;87(1):44-51. doi: 10.2175/106143014x14062131179032.
In this study, two sample semi-analytical algorithms and one new unified multi-band semi-analytical algorithm (UMSA) for estimating chlorophyll-a (Chla) concentration were constructed by specifying optimal wavelengths. The three sample semi-analytical algorithms, including the three-band semi-analytical algorithm (TSA), four-band semi-analytical algorithm (FSA), and UMSA algorithm, were calibrated and validated by the dataset collected in the Yellow River Estuary between September 1 and 10, 2009. By comparing of the accuracy of assessment of TSA, FSA, and UMSA algorithms, it was found that the UMSA algorithm had a superior performance in comparison with the two other algorithms, TSA and FSA. Using the UMSA algorithm in retrieving Chla concentration in the Yellow River Estuary decreased by 25.54% NRMSE (normalized root mean square error) when compared with the FSA algorithm, and 29.66% NRMSE in comparison with the TSA algorithm. These are very significant improvements upon previous methods. Additionally, the study revealed that the TSA and FSA algorithms are merely more specific forms of the UMSA algorithm. Owing to the special form of the UMSA algorithm, if the same bands were used for both the TSA and UMSA algorithms or FSA and UMSA algorithms, the UMSA algorithm would theoretically produce superior results in comparison with the TSA and FSA algorithms. Thus, good results may also be produced if the UMSA algorithm were to be applied for predicting Chla concentration for datasets of Gitelson et al. (2008) and Le et al. (2009).
在本研究中,通过指定最佳波长构建了两种样本半解析算法和一种新的统一多波段半解析算法(UMSA)来估算叶绿素a(Chla)浓度。这三种样本半解析算法,包括三波段半解析算法(TSA)、四波段半解析算法(FSA)和UMSA算法,通过2009年9月1日至10日在黄河口收集的数据集进行了校准和验证。通过比较TSA、FSA和UMSA算法的评估精度,发现UMSA算法与其他两种算法TSA和FSA相比具有更优的性能。与FSA算法相比,在黄河口使用UMSA算法反演Chla浓度时,归一化均方根误差(NRMSE)降低了25.54%,与TSA算法相比降低了29.66%。这些都是相对于以前方法的非常显著的改进。此外,研究表明TSA和FSA算法仅仅是UMSA算法的更特殊形式。由于UMSA算法的特殊形式,如果TSA和UMSA算法或FSA和UMSA算法使用相同的波段,理论上UMSA算法与TSA和FSA算法相比会产生更优的结果。因此,如果将UMSA算法应用于预测Gitelson等人(2008年)和Le等人(2009年)的数据集中的Chla浓度,也可能会产生良好的结果。