Wells Lloyd A
Department of Psychiatry and Psychology, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN, USA.
J Eval Clin Pract. 2015 Jun;21(3):514-7. doi: 10.1111/jep.12324. Epub 2015 Feb 4.
I discuss the lack of precision in the term 'clinical reasoning' and its relationship to evidence-based medicine and critical thinking. I examine critical thinking skills, their underemphasis in medical education and successful attempts to remediate them. Evidence-based medicine (and evidence-based psychiatry) offer much but are hampered by the ubiquity and flaws of meta-analysis. I explore views of evidence-based medicine among psychiatry residents, as well as capacity for critical thinking in residents before and after a course in philosophy. I discuss decision making by experienced doctors and suggest possible futures of this issue.
我讨论了“临床推理”一词缺乏精确性的问题,以及它与循证医学和批判性思维的关系。我审视了批判性思维技能、它们在医学教育中未得到充分重视的情况,以及补救这些问题的成功尝试。循证医学(以及循证精神病学)有很多贡献,但受到荟萃分析的普遍性和缺陷的阻碍。我探讨了精神病学住院医师对循证医学的看法,以及在参加哲学课程前后住院医师的批判性思维能力。我讨论了经验丰富的医生的决策过程,并提出了这个问题可能的未来发展方向。