Onyemaechi Ndubuisi Oc, Lasebikan Omolade A, Elachi Itodo C, Popoola Sunday O, Oluwadiya Kehinde S
Department of Surgery, University of Nigeria Teaching Hospital, Ituku-Ozalla, Enugu, Nigeria.
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, National Orthopaedic Hospital, Enugu, Nigeria.
Patient Prefer Adherence. 2015 Feb 9;9:275-9. doi: 10.2147/PPA.S76877. eCollection 2015.
Despite the numerous complications associated with traditional bonesetters' (TBS) practices, their patronage has remained high in developing countries. The aim was to study the reasons patients seek TBS treatment.
This was a descriptive hospital-based study of 120 patients who were treated by TBS. The sociodemographic profile of the patients, details of injuries sustained, reasons for TBS patronage, duration of TBS treatment, the number of TBS visited, the reason for abandoning TBS treatment, patients' belief about the TBS practice, and outcome of their treatment were studied.
Out of 418 patients who presented with musculoskeletal injuries, 120 patients who had been treated by TBS before presentation met the inclusion criteria. The mean age of the patients was 37.4±10.5 years. Advice of relatives and friends, as seen in 35 (29.2%) patients, was the most common reason for TBS patronage. Other reasons were cheaper cost (number [n]=30; 25%), sociocultural belief (n=17; 14.2%), easy accessibility (n=15; 12.5%), fear of amputation (n=13; 108%), and fear of operation (n=10; 8.3%). There was no correlation between these factors and age, marital status, occupation, and educational status (P=0.41). Forty-two (35%) patients believed TBS were not useful, a nuisance (n=30; 25%), useful (n=38; 31.7%), or indispensable (n=10; 8.3%). The opinion of patients about the outcome of TBS practice was: very satisfactory (n=0; 0%); satisfactory but with deficiencies (n=24; 20%); unsatisfactory (n=80; 66.7%); and no idea (n=16; 13.3%).
Advice of relatives and friends was the main reason for patronizing TBS. The majority of patients lost confidence in the TBS practice after patronizing them due to the high complication rate.
尽管传统接骨师的做法存在诸多并发症,但在发展中国家,寻求其治疗的患者数量仍然居高不下。本研究旨在探究患者寻求传统接骨师治疗的原因。
这是一项基于医院的描述性研究,共纳入120例接受传统接骨师治疗的患者。研究内容包括患者的社会人口学特征、受伤细节、寻求传统接骨师治疗的原因、治疗时长、就诊的传统接骨师数量、放弃治疗的原因、患者对传统接骨师治疗的看法以及治疗结果。
在418例出现肌肉骨骼损伤的患者中,120例在就诊前接受过传统接骨师治疗的患者符合纳入标准。患者的平均年龄为37.4±10.5岁。35例(29.2%)患者表示,亲朋好友的建议是他们寻求传统接骨师治疗最常见的原因。其他原因包括费用较低(30例,25%)、社会文化信仰(17例,14.2%)、易于就诊(15例,12.5%)、害怕截肢(13例,10.8%)以及害怕手术(10例,8.3%)。这些因素与年龄、婚姻状况、职业和教育程度之间无相关性(P = 0.41)。42例(35%)患者认为传统接骨师治疗无用,是一种麻烦(30例,25%),有用(38例,31.7%)或不可或缺(10例,8.3%)。患者对传统接骨师治疗结果的看法为:非常满意(0例,0%);满意但有不足(24例,20%);不满意(80例,66.7%);不清楚(16例,13.3%)。
亲朋好友的建议是患者寻求传统接骨师治疗的主要原因。由于并发症发生率高,大多数患者在接受传统接骨师治疗后对其治疗方法失去信心。