Beaulieu Yanick, Laprise Réjean, Drolet Pierre, Thivierge Robert L, Serri Karim, Albert Martin, Lamontagne Alain, Bélliveau Marc, Denault André-Yves, Patenaude Jean-Victor
Faculty of Medicine, Department of Medicine and Hôpital Sacré-Coeur, 5400 boul. Gouin ouest, Montréal, H4J 1C5 Canada.
Faculty of Medicine, Department of Medicine and Centre d'Apprentissage des Attitudes et Habiletés Cliniques (CAAHC), Université de Montréal, 2900 boul. Edouard-Montpetit, Montréal, H3T 1J4 Canada.
Crit Ultrasound J. 2015 Jan 21;7:1. doi: 10.1186/s13089-014-0018-9. eCollection 2015.
Focused bedside ultrasound is rapidly becoming a standard of care to decrease the risks of complications related to invasive procedures. The purpose of this study was to assess whether adding to the curriculum of junior residents an educational intervention combining web-based e-learning and hands-on training would improve the residents' proficiency in different clinical applications of bedside ultrasound as compared to using the traditional apprenticeship teaching method alone.
Junior residents (n = 39) were provided with two educational interventions (vascular and pleural ultrasound). Each intervention consisted of a combination of web-based e-learning and bedside hands-on training. Senior residents (n = 15) were the traditionally trained group and were not provided with the educational interventions.
After the educational intervention, performance of the junior residents on the practical tests was superior to that of the senior residents. This was true for the vascular assessment (94% ± 5% vs. 68% ± 15%, unpaired student t test: p < 0.0001, mean difference: 26 (95% CI: 20 to 31)) and even more significant for the pleural assessment (92% ± 9% vs. 57% ± 25%, unpaired student t test: p < 0.0001, mean difference: 35 (95% CI: 23 to 44)). The junior residents also had a significantly higher success rate in performing ultrasound-guided needle insertion compared to the senior residents for both the transverse (95% vs. 60%, Fisher's exact test p = 0.0048) and longitudinal views (100% vs. 73%, Fisher's exact test p = 0.0055).
Our study demonstrated that a structured curriculum combining web-based education, hands-on training, and simulation integrated early in the training of the junior residents can lead to better proficiency in performing ultrasound-guided techniques compared to the traditional apprenticeship model.
床旁聚焦超声正迅速成为一种降低侵入性操作相关并发症风险的标准医疗手段。本研究的目的是评估,相较于仅使用传统的师徒教学法,在初级住院医师的课程中增加基于网络的电子学习与实践培训相结合的教育干预措施,是否会提高住院医师在床旁超声不同临床应用中的熟练程度。
为初级住院医师(n = 39)提供了两种教育干预措施(血管超声和胸膜超声)。每种干预措施都包括基于网络的电子学习和床旁实践培训。高级住院医师(n = 15)为传统培训组,未接受教育干预措施。
经过教育干预后,初级住院医师在实践测试中的表现优于高级住院医师。在血管评估方面(94% ± 5% 对 68% ± 15%,非配对学生t检验:p < 0.0001,平均差异:26(95%可信区间:20至31))确实如此,而在胸膜评估方面(92% ± 9% 对 57% ± 25%,非配对学生t检验:p < 0.0001,平均差异:35(95%可信区间:23至44))更为显著。在进行超声引导下的穿刺针插入操作时,初级住院医师在横向视图(95%对60%,Fisher精确检验p = 0.0048)和纵向视图(100%对73%,Fisher精确检验p = 0.0055)方面的成功率也显著高于高级住院医师。
我们的研究表明,与传统的师徒模式相比,在初级住院医师培训早期整合基于网络的教育、实践培训和模拟的结构化课程,可使他们在执行超声引导技术方面达到更高的熟练程度。