Barnes-Holmes Dermot, Hussey Ian
Department of Psychology, Ghent University, Henri Dunantlaan 2, B-9000 Ghent, Belgium.
Department of Psychology, National University of Ireland Maynooth, Kildare, Republic of Ireland.
Int J Psychol. 2016 Feb;51(1):50-7. doi: 10.1002/ijop.12166. Epub 2015 Apr 15.
The functional-cognitive meta-theoretical framework has been offered as a conceptual basis for facilitating greater communication and cooperation between the functional/behavioural and cognitive traditions within psychology, thus leading to benefits for both scientific communities. The current article is written from the perspective of two functional researchers, who are also proponents of the functional-cognitive framework, and attended the "Building Bridges between the Functional and Cognitive Traditions" meeting at Ghent University in the summer of 2014. The article commences with a brief summary of the functional approach to theory, followed by our reflections upon the functional-cognitive framework in light of that meeting. In doing so, we offer three ways in which the framework could be clarified: (a) effective communication between the two traditions is likely to be found at the level of behavioural observations rather than effects or theory, (b) not all behavioural observations will be deemed to be of mutual interest to both traditions, and (c) observations of mutual interest will be those that serve to elaborate and extend existing theorising in the functional and/or cognitive traditions. The article concludes with a summary of what we perceive to be the strengths and weaknesses of the framework, and a suggestion that there is a need to determine if the framework is meta-theoretical or is in fact a third theoretical approach to doing psychological science.
功能认知元理论框架已被提出,作为促进心理学中功能/行为传统与认知传统之间加强交流与合作的概念基础,从而使两个科学界都受益。本文是由两位功能研究人员撰写的,他们也是功能认知框架的支持者,并参加了2014年夏天在根特大学举行的“搭建功能传统与认知传统之间的桥梁”会议。文章开篇简要概述了理论的功能方法,接着是我们根据那次会议对功能认知框架的思考。在此过程中,我们提出了三种可以阐明该框架的方式:(a) 两种传统之间的有效交流可能存在于行为观察层面,而非效应或理论层面;(b) 并非所有行为观察都将被视为对两种传统都具有共同兴趣;(c) 具有共同兴趣的观察将是那些有助于阐述和扩展功能传统和/或认知传统中现有理论的观察。文章最后总结了我们认为该框架的优点和缺点,并提出有必要确定该框架是元理论还是实际上是进行心理学研究的第三种理论方法。