Theobald Peter S, Qureshi Assad, Jones Michael D
Trauma Biomechanics Research Group, Institute of Medical Engineering and Medical Physics, Cardiff University, The Parade, Cardiff CF24 3AA, UK.
Division of Orthopaedic and Accident Surgery, University of Nottingham, Queens Medical Centre, Nottingham NG7 2UH, UK.
J Clin Orthop Trauma. 2012 Jun;3(1):24-7. doi: 10.1016/j.jcot.2012.02.001. Epub 2012 Jun 16.
Approximately 50% of infant and toddler long bone fractures are attributed to non-accidental trauma; however, differentiating from benign mechanisms is subjective, due to an absence of evidence-based diagnostic tools. Previous studies investigated small ranges of rotational velocities in animal long bone models, although did not report the variation in the spiral fracture angle. This study considered the fracture angle as a potential clinical measure, correlating this data with a wider range of rotational velocities. The spiral fracture angle was measured relative to the long axis, whilst noting the narrowest diaphysial diameter, location of the fracture, and the extent of comminution and periosteal disruption. Twenty-six bones failed in spiral fracture, with the potting material failing in the remaining tests. All spiral fractures centred on the narrowest diaphysial diameter. Slower rotational velocities caused fracture angles approaching 45°, whereas fractures at greater velocities caused fracture angles nearer 30°. A relatively strong trend (R (2) = 0.78) is reported when the normalised fracture angle (against the narrowest diaphysial dimension) was plotted against the rotational rate. A relationship has been identified between the angle of spiral fracture and the rotational velocity using the immature bovine metatarsal model. This trend forms a scientific foundation from which to explore developing a diagnostic, evidence-based tool that may ultimately serve to assist differentiating between accidental and non-accidental injury.
约50%的婴幼儿长骨骨折归因于非意外创伤;然而,由于缺乏循证诊断工具,与良性机制相区分具有主观性。以往研究在动物长骨模型中研究了小范围的旋转速度,但未报告螺旋骨折角度的变化。本研究将骨折角度视为一种潜在的临床指标,将该数据与更广泛的旋转速度范围相关联。相对于长轴测量螺旋骨折角度,同时记录骨干最窄直径、骨折位置以及粉碎程度和骨膜破坏情况。26根骨头发生螺旋骨折,其余测试中灌封材料失效。所有螺旋骨折均以骨干最窄直径为中心。较慢的旋转速度导致骨折角度接近45°,而较快速度下的骨折导致骨折角度接近30°。当将标准化骨折角度(相对于骨干最窄尺寸)与旋转速率作图时,报告了一种相对较强的趋势(R(2)=0.78)。使用未成熟牛跖骨模型已确定螺旋骨折角度与旋转速度之间的关系。这一趋势形成了一个科学基础,据此可探索开发一种循证诊断工具,最终可能有助于区分意外和非意外伤害。