Pfoh Elizabeth, Mojtabai Ramin, Bailey Jennifer, Weiner Jonathan P, Dy Sydney M
Dr. Pfoh is with the Division of General Internal Medicine, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore (e-mail:
Psychiatr Serv. 2015 Nov;66(11):1207-12. doi: 10.1176/appi.ps.201400524. Epub 2015 Jul 15.
Depression screening is a required part of an initial annual wellness visit (AWV), a benefit for Medicare Part B beneficiaries. It is uncertain whether AWVs will increase depression screening. This study assessed whether patients with an AWV were more likely to be screened for depression than those with a primary care visit.
A cross-sectional analysis of electronic health record data was conducted for 4,245 Medicare patients who had at least one primary care visit at one of 34 practices within a large multisite provider network between September 2010 and August 2012. Quota sampling was used so that half of the participants had an AWV and half had a randomly selected primary care visit during the study period (the index visit). Multilevel logistic regressions were used to determine whether patients with an AWV had increased odds of depression screening compared with patients with a primary care visit, after adjustment for physician and clinic clustering.
Fifteen percent of patients with non-AWVs and 10% of patients with AWVs received depression screening. After accounting for clustering, there was no statistically significant difference in depression screening by visit type. There was a strong site effect, with one site conducting screening during 78% of AWVs and 82% of non-AWVs. Six sites screened none of their patients.
Overall, depression screening during the index AWV was uncommon. By itself, the AWV benefit does not appear to be a strong enough incentive to increase depression screening.
抑郁症筛查是初次年度健康检查(AWV)的必要组成部分,这是医疗保险B部分受益人的一项福利。目前尚不确定AWV是否会增加抑郁症筛查。本研究评估了接受AWV的患者是否比接受初级保健就诊的患者更有可能接受抑郁症筛查。
对2010年9月至2012年8月期间在一个大型多地点医疗服务网络内34家医疗机构中至少有一次初级保健就诊的4245名医疗保险患者的电子健康记录数据进行横断面分析。采用配额抽样,使一半参与者在研究期间(索引就诊)接受AWV,另一半接受随机选择的初级保健就诊。在对医生和诊所聚类进行调整后,使用多水平逻辑回归来确定与接受初级保健就诊的患者相比,接受AWV的患者抑郁症筛查几率是否增加。
未接受AWV的患者中有15%接受了抑郁症筛查,接受AWV的患者中有10%接受了筛查。在考虑聚类因素后,按就诊类型进行的抑郁症筛查在统计学上没有显著差异。存在很强的机构效应,一个机构在78%的AWV和82%的非AWV期间进行筛查。六个机构未对其任何患者进行筛查。
总体而言,索引AWV期间的抑郁症筛查并不常见。就其本身而言,AWV福利似乎并不是增加抑郁症筛查的足够有力的激励措施。