Tofthagen Cindy, Boses Sarah, Healy Gene, Jooma Nuruddin
1 College of Nursing, University of South Florida , Tampa, Florida.
2 Integrative Oncology Department, Florida Cancer Specialists , Largo, Florida.
J Palliat Med. 2015 Oct;18(10):878-80. doi: 10.1089/jpm.2015.0143. Epub 2015 Jul 28.
Acupuncture is being used for treatment of cancer-related symptoms in numerous settings, yet empirical evidence supporting the effects of acupuncture in this setting is lacking. Group acupuncture is an economical way to provide acupuncture to patients at a reduced cost.
In this retrospective study we sought to evaluate the effects of group acupuncture on specific cancer-related symptoms in persons receiving outpatient cancer treatment.
Patients were receiving group acupuncture treatments through an integrative oncology program in a large community oncology practice in west central Florida. A short patient-completed assessment of seven basic cancer-related symptoms using a 0-10 numeric rating scale was completed at each acupuncture treatment. Basic demographic information, including age, gender, race/ethnicity, and cancer type was obtained from the medical record. Paired sample t-tests were used to evaluate differences in symptoms before the first treatment and at the fourth treatment.
Fifty patients completed at least four weekly acupuncture treatments in 2014. Forty-three of them completed symptom assessments and were included in this analysis. The mean age of participants was 66.4 years. The majority of patients were white, non-Hispanic, and female. No significant improvement in symptoms were identified at the third treatment. At the time of the fourth group acupuncture, participants reported significantly less pain/numbness and problems with digestion.
The results of this study provide evidence to support the efficacy of group acupuncture for pain, neuropathy, and digestive problems in persons with cancer. A minimum of four weekly treatments may be necessary before improvements are noted. Limitations include a retrospective design, incomplete symptom evaluation, and possible response bias. Future studies of group acupuncture for cancer-related symptoms should utilize a prospective, controlled design, use validated measures to thoroughly evaluate targeted symptoms, and include a more racially and ethnically diverse sample.
针刺疗法正在众多环境中用于治疗癌症相关症状,但缺乏支持针刺疗法在此环境中效果的实证证据。集体针刺疗法是一种以较低成本为患者提供针刺治疗的经济方式。
在这项回顾性研究中,我们试图评估集体针刺疗法对接受门诊癌症治疗患者特定癌症相关症状的影响。
患者通过佛罗里达州中西部一个大型社区肿瘤诊所的综合肿瘤项目接受集体针刺治疗。在每次针刺治疗时,患者使用0至10的数字评分量表完成一份简短的、关于七种基本癌症相关症状的自我评估。从病历中获取包括年龄、性别、种族/民族和癌症类型在内的基本人口统计学信息。使用配对样本t检验来评估首次治疗前和第四次治疗时症状的差异。
2014年,50名患者完成了至少四周的针刺治疗。其中43名患者完成了症状评估并纳入本分析。参与者的平均年龄为66.4岁。大多数患者为非西班牙裔白人女性。第三次治疗时未发现症状有显著改善。在第四次集体针刺治疗时,参与者报告疼痛/麻木和消化问题明显减轻。
本研究结果为支持集体针刺疗法对癌症患者的疼痛、神经病变和消化问题的疗效提供了证据。在症状出现改善之前,可能需要至少四周的治疗。局限性包括回顾性设计、症状评估不完整以及可能的反应偏倚。未来关于集体针刺疗法治疗癌症相关症状的研究应采用前瞻性、对照设计,使用经过验证的测量方法全面评估目标症状,并纳入更具种族和民族多样性的样本。