Grimsby G M, Harrison S M, Granberg C F, Bernstein I H, Baker L A
Department of Urology, University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center, Dallas, TX, USA.
Department of Urology, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN, USA.
J Pediatr Urol. 2015 Oct;11(5):280.e1-6. doi: 10.1016/j.jpurol.2015.06.005. Epub 2015 Jul 9.
Prune belly syndrome (PBS) extra-genitourinary (extra-GU) manifestations are serious comorbidities beyond the genitourinary (GU) anomalies of this disease. We hypothesized an underestimation of the reported frequency and understated impact on quality of life (QOL) of extra-GU comorbidities in PBS survivors beyond the newborn period. To assess this, the frequencies of extra-GU manifestations of PBS in a contemporary cohort of living patients were compared to compiled frequencies from published literature. Second, the impact of extra-GU PBS manifestations on patient/family QOL was assessed via a non-validated open-ended survey.
From 2010 to 2013, PBS survivors were prospectively recruited locally or at three PBS Network National Conventions. The family/subject was asked to complete a detailed PBS questionnaire, non-validated QOL survey, and provide medical records for review. Clinical data were extracted from medical records for local patients. The frequencies of extra-GU manifestations were compared between the contemporary, living cohort and a published literature cohort derived from PubMed.
Seven of 706 published studies met criteria for frequencies tabulation of extra-GU PBS manifestations. This largest reported living PBS patient cohort (n = 65) was 99% male with mean age 10 years (1 month-45 years). The living PBS cohort had a statistically significantly higher incidence of gastrointestinal (63%), orthopedic (65%), and cardiopulmonary (49%) diagnoses compared to the compiled published cohort (n = 204). Eleven PBS males and 32 family members completed the QOL survey. Of these, 47% listed at least one non-GU problem (i.e. lung disease, skeletal problems, constipation) as negatively affecting their QOL; 42% listed at least one GU problem (i.e. self-catheterization, recurrent UTIs) as negatively affecting their QOL; 56% reported musculoskeletal surgery and 21% reported gastrointestinal surgery/medication as positively impacting their QOL.
In this large contemporary series, surviving individuals with PBS had a significantly higher incidence of orthopedic, gastrointestinal, and cardiopulmonary diagnoses than previously reported in PBS publications. From the patient/family QOL perspective, non-GU PBS manifestations negatively impact their QOL and treatment of these non-GU conditions improves their lives. As urologic surgeons for these medically complex patients, it is extremely important to be aware of and prepare for the high incidence of non-GU PBS comorbidities directly impacting the medical and surgical treatment and QOL of PBS patients and their families.
梅干腹综合征(PBS)的泌尿生殖系统外(extra-GU)表现是该疾病泌尿生殖系统(GU)异常之外的严重合并症。我们推测,在新生儿期之后的PBS幸存者中,泌尿生殖系统外合并症的报告频率被低估,且对生活质量(QOL)的影响也未得到充分重视。为评估这一点,我们将当代一组存活患者中PBS的泌尿生殖系统外表现频率与已发表文献中汇总的频率进行了比较。其次,通过一项未经验证的开放式调查,评估了泌尿生殖系统外PBS表现对患者/家庭生活质量的影响。
2010年至2013年,前瞻性招募了当地或在三个PBS网络全国大会上的PBS幸存者。要求家庭/受试者填写一份详细的PBS问卷、未经验证的生活质量调查问卷,并提供病历以供审查。从当地患者的病历中提取临床数据。将当代存活队列与从PubMed获取的已发表文献队列中泌尿生殖系统外表现的频率进行比较。
706项已发表研究中有7项符合泌尿生殖系统外PBS表现频率列表的标准。这个报告的最大的存活PBS患者队列(n = 65)中,99%为男性,平均年龄10岁(1个月至45岁)。与汇总的已发表队列(n = 204)相比,当代存活的PBS队列中胃肠道(63%)、骨科(65%)和心肺(49%)诊断的发生率在统计学上显著更高。11名PBS男性患者和32名家庭成员完成了生活质量调查。其中,47%列出至少一项非泌尿生殖系统问题(如肺部疾病、骨骼问题、便秘)对其生活质量有负面影响;42%列出至少一项泌尿生殖系统问题(如自行导尿、复发性尿路感染)对其生活质量有负面影响;56%报告肌肉骨骼手术,21%报告胃肠道手术/药物治疗对其生活质量有积极影响。
在这个大型当代系列研究中,存活的PBS个体中骨科、胃肠道和心肺诊断的发生率明显高于PBS相关出版物中先前报道的发生率。从患者/家庭生活质量的角度来看,泌尿生殖系统外PBS表现对其生活质量有负面影响,而对这些非泌尿生殖系统疾病的治疗可改善他们的生活。作为这些医疗复杂患者的泌尿外科医生,了解并为直接影响PBS患者及其家庭的医疗和手术治疗以及生活质量的泌尿生殖系统外PBS合并症的高发生率做好准备极其重要。