van Rijsingen Margit C J, Seubring Inge, Grutters Janneke P C, Maessen-Visch M Birgitte, Alkemade Hans A C, van Doorn Remco, Groenewoud Hans, van de Kerkhof Peter C M, van der Wilt Gert Jan, Gerritsen Marie-Jeanne P
Department of Dermatology, Radboud University Medical Centre, 6500 HB Nijmegen, The Netherlands.
Acta Derm Venereol. 2016 Mar;96(3):346-50. doi: 10.2340/00015555-2216.
Actinic keratoses (AK) occur frequently; however, real-life clinical data on personalized treatment choice and costs are scarce. This multicentre one-year observational study investigated patient-characteristics, cost and effectiveness of methylaminolaevulinate photodynamic therapy (MAL-PDT), imiquimod (IMI) and 5-fluorour-acil (5-FU) in patients with AKs on the face/scalp. A total of 104 patients preferred MAL-PDT, 106 preferred IMI and 110 preferred 5-FU. At baseline, significant differences between treatment groups were found; most patients were severely affected (mean 32.5 AK in PDT-group, 20.2 in IMI-group, 22.8 in 5-FU-group). A mean reduction in lesions of 81% after MAL-PDT, 82% after IMI and 88% after 5-FU was found after one year. Annual costs were €1,950 for MAL-PDT, €877 for IMI and €738 for 5-FU. These results show that, compared with clinical trials, in the real-life clinical setting AK patients are usually more severely affected and treatment costs are much higher. Furthermore, patient characteristics are important factors in treatment choice.
光化性角化病(AK)很常见;然而,关于个性化治疗选择和成本的实际临床数据却很匮乏。这项多中心的为期一年的观察性研究调查了面部/头皮患有AK的患者的特征、甲基氨基乙酰丙酸光动力疗法(MAL-PDT)、咪喹莫特(IMI)和5-氟尿嘧啶(5-FU)的成本及疗效。共有104例患者倾向于MAL-PDT,106例倾向于IMI,110例倾向于5-FU。在基线时,发现治疗组之间存在显著差异;大多数患者病情严重(PDT组平均有32.5个AK,IMI组为20.2个,5-FU组为22.8个)。一年后,发现MAL-PDT后病变平均减少81%,IMI后减少82%,5-FU后减少88%。MAL-PDT的年度成本为1950欧元,IMI为877欧元,5-FU为738欧元。这些结果表明,与临床试验相比,在实际临床环境中,AK患者通常病情更严重,治疗成本更高。此外,患者特征是治疗选择的重要因素。