Farkhondeh Alireza, Geist James R
J Mich Dent Assoc. 2015 Jul;97(7):34-8.
The objective was to evaluate the effectiveness of Web-based interactive modules in the instruction of dental hygiene students on intraoral and panoramic radiographic landmarks. The experimental group studied these landmarks as presented on interactive Web-based modules instead of in classroom presentations. The control group (the previous year's class) received instruction in the traditional classroom format. The outcomes measures included quizzes, examinations and an in-class project. Independent samples t-tests compared the scores of the two groups. A survey was administered to the experimental group to determine their perceptions of instruction with the modules. There was no significant difference in scores between the two groups on the project (p = .926) or the intraoral quiz and exam scores (p = .1 22), but the experimental group scored significantly lower on the panoramic outcomes (p = .039). Only 26% of the students preferred computer-assisted instruction to classroom instruction. The narration and interactive quizzes in the intraoral module may have contributed to the similar performance of the experimental and control groups, while their absence may have adversely affected the effectiveness of the panoramic module.
目的是评估基于网络的交互式模块在口腔卫生专业学生口腔内和全景放射影像标志教学中的有效性。实验组通过基于网络的交互式模块学习这些标志,而非在课堂讲授中学习。对照组(前一年的班级)以传统课堂形式接受教学。结果测量包括测验、考试和课堂项目。独立样本t检验比较了两组的分数。对实验组进行了一项调查,以确定他们对使用这些模块教学的看法。两组在项目(p = 0.926)、口腔内测验和考试分数(p = 0.122)上的得分没有显著差异,但实验组在全景影像结果上的得分显著较低(p = 0.039)。只有26%的学生更喜欢计算机辅助教学而非课堂教学。口腔内模块中的旁白和交互式测验可能促成了实验组和对照组的相似表现,而它们的缺失可能对全景模块的有效性产生了不利影响。