Institute for Medical Technology Assessment, Health Policy & Management, Erasmus University Rotterdam, PO Box 1738, Rotterdam 3000 DR, The Netherlands
Department of Health Economics and Reimbursement, Medtronic, Route du Molliau 31, Tolochenaz 1131, Switzerland.
Europace. 2016 Jun;18(6):919-24. doi: 10.1093/europace/euv217. Epub 2015 Aug 19.
Implantable cardiac monitors (ICMs) are used for long-term heart rhythm monitoring, e.g. to diagnose unexplained syncope or for detection of suspected atrial and ventricular arrhythmias. The newest ICM, Reveal LINQ™ (Medtronic Inc.), is miniaturized and inserted with a specific insertion tool kit. The procedure is therefore minimally invasive and can be moved from catheterization laboratory (cath lab) to a less resource intensive setting. This study aims to assess the change in procedure costs when performed outside the cath lab.
A bottom-up costing methodology was used. Data were collected from interviews with physicians, cath lab managers, and financial controllers. Hospitals in the Netherlands, France, and the UK were included in this study. The cost comparison of a Reveal XT implantation in a cath lab setting vs. a Reveal LINQ insertion outside a cath lab resulted in an estimated reduction of €662 for the UK, €682 for the Netherlands, and €781 for France. These cost savings were primarily realized through fewer staff, less equipment, and overhead costs. The net effect on savings depends on the price differential between these two technologies. The patient care pathway can be improved due to the possibility to move the procedure out of the cath lab.
Inserting the miniaturized version of the ICM is simpler and faster, and the procedure can take place outside the cath lab in a less resource intensive environment. Hospitals save resources when the higher price of the Reveal LINQ does not outweigh these savings.
植入式心脏监测器 (ICM) 用于长期心律监测,例如诊断不明原因的晕厥或检测疑似房性和室性心律失常。最新的 ICM,即 Reveal LINQ™(美敦力公司),体积缩小,并使用特定的插入工具包进行插入。因此,该程序具有微创性,可以从导管实验室 (cath lab) 转移到资源需求较低的环境。本研究旨在评估在 cath lab 之外进行时程序成本的变化。
使用自下而上的成本核算方法。数据是通过采访医生、cath lab 经理和财务控制员收集的。本研究纳入了荷兰、法国和英国的医院。在 cath lab 环境下进行 Reveal XT 植入与在 cath lab 外进行 Reveal LINQ 插入的成本比较,结果显示英国的估计成本降低了 662 欧元,荷兰降低了 682 欧元,法国降低了 781 欧元。这些成本节约主要是通过减少人员、设备和间接费用实现的。节省的净效果取决于这两种技术的价格差异。由于有可能将该程序移出 cath lab,患者护理路径可以得到改善。
插入 ICM 的小型化版本更简单、更快,并且可以在资源需求较低的环境中在 cath lab 之外进行该程序。当 Reveal LINQ 的较高价格没有超过这些节省时,医院可以节省资源。