Caron Louis
Med Hist. 2015 Oct;59(4):525-53. doi: 10.1017/mdh.2015.45.
This article provides a new consideration of how Thomas Willis (1621-75) came to write the first works of 'neurology', which was in its time a novel use of cerebral and neural anatomy to defend philosophical claims about the mind. Willis's neurology was shaped by the immediate political and religious contexts of the English Civil War and Restoration. Accordingly, the majority of this paper is devoted to uncovering the political necessities Willis faced during the Restoration of the English monarchy in 1660, with particular focus on the significance of Willis's dedication of his neurology and natural philosophy to the Archbishop of Canterbury, Gilbert Sheldon. Because the Restoration of Charles II brought only a semblance of order and peace, Willis and his allies understood the need for a coherent defense of the authority of the English church and its liturgy. Of particular importance to Sheldon and Willis (and to others in Sheldon's circle) were the specific ceremonies described in the Book of Common Prayer, a manual that directed the congregation to assume various postures during public worship. This article demonstrates that Willis's neurology should be read as an intervention in these debates, that his neurology would have been read at the time as an attempt to ground orthodox worship in the structure of the brain and nerves. The political necessities that helped to shape Willis's project also help us to better understand Willis's innovative insistence that philosophical statements about the mind should be formulated only after a comprehensive anatomical investigation of the brain and nerves.
本文对托马斯·威利斯(1621 - 1675)如何写出首批“神经学”著作进行了新的思考,在当时,这是一种利用大脑和神经解剖学来捍卫关于心灵的哲学主张的新颖做法。威利斯的神经学受到英国内战和复辟时期直接的政治及宗教背景的影响。因此,本文的大部分内容致力于揭示威利斯在1660年英国君主复辟期间所面临的政治必要性,特别关注威利斯将其神经学和自然哲学献给坎特伯雷大主教吉尔伯特·谢尔登的意义。由于查理二世的复辟仅带来了表面上的秩序与和平,威利斯及其盟友明白需要对英国教会及其礼拜仪式的权威进行连贯的捍卫。对谢尔登和威利斯(以及谢尔登圈子里的其他人)而言,《公祷书》中描述的特定仪式尤为重要,该手册指导会众在公共礼拜期间采取各种姿势。本文表明,威利斯的神经学应被视为对这些辩论的一种介入,他的神经学在当时会被解读为试图将正统礼拜建立在大脑和神经结构的基础之上。塑造威利斯这一计划的政治必要性也有助于我们更好地理解威利斯的创新观点,即关于心灵的哲学陈述应仅在对大脑和神经进行全面解剖学研究之后才得以形成。