Hatch Daniel J, Smith Abigail, Fowler Troy
Surgeon, Foot and Ankle, Medical Center of the Rockies, Loveland, CO; North Colorado Medical Center, Greeley, CO.
PGY-2 Resident, North Colorado Medical Center, Greeley, CO.
J Foot Ankle Surg. 2016 Jan-Feb;55(1):85-9. doi: 10.1053/j.jfas.2015.06.026. Epub 2015 Sep 7.
The angle formed by the distal articular facet of the medial cuneiform has been evaluated and discussed by various investigators. However, no consistent method has been available to radiograph and measure this entity. The wide variability of the angle is not conducive to comparative analysis. Additionally, investigators have noted that the angles observed (obliquity) vary greatly because of changes in radiographic angle, foot position, rotation of the first ray, and declination of the first metatarsal. Recognizing that these variables exist, we propose a reproducible assessment using digital radiography and application of deformity of correction principles. Our results have indicated a mean distal medial cuneiform angle of 20.69° in normal feet, 23.51° with moderate hallux valgus, and 20.41° with severe hallux valgus deformity. The radiograph beam was kept at 15° from the coronal plane. An inverse relationship was found between the distal medial cuneiform angle and bunion severity. This was in contrast to our expected hypothesis. The overall angle of the first metatarsal-medial cuneiform did, however, correlate with the severity of the bunion deformity (p < .000). The obliquity values and intermetatarsal angles changed in direct relationship to the radiographic projection angle. This illustrates the importance of using standardized radiographic projection angles. We conclude that the 1-dimensional standard anteroposterior radiograph with assessment of the distal medial cuneiform angle cannot adequately demonstrate the pathologic features of hallux valgus. A better indicator appears to be the first metatarsal-medial cuneiform angle. This pathologic entity is a 3-dimensional one that incorporates the joint morphology of the first ray, triplane osseous positioning, and soft tissue imbalances. Perhaps, 3-dimensional computed tomography imaging will provide better insight into this entity.
多位研究者已对内侧楔骨远侧关节面所形成的角度进行了评估和讨论。然而,目前尚无一致的方法来对该结构进行放射成像和测量。该角度的广泛变异性不利于进行对比分析。此外,研究者们指出,由于放射成像角度、足部位置、第一跖骨旋转以及第一跖骨倾斜度的变化,所观察到的角度(倾斜度)差异很大。认识到这些变量的存在后,我们提出了一种使用数字放射成像和应用矫正畸形原则的可重复评估方法。我们的结果表明,正常足部的内侧楔骨远侧平均角度为20.69°,中度拇外翻时为23.51°,重度拇外翻畸形时为20.41°。放射成像束与冠状面保持15°夹角。发现内侧楔骨远侧角度与拇囊炎严重程度呈负相关。这与我们预期的假设相反。然而,第一跖骨 - 内侧楔骨的整体角度确实与拇囊炎畸形的严重程度相关(p <.000)。倾斜度值和跖骨间角度与放射成像投影角度呈直接关系。这说明了使用标准化放射成像投影角度的重要性。我们得出结论,通过评估内侧楔骨远侧角度的一维标准前后位放射成像不能充分显示拇外翻的病理特征。一个更好的指标似乎是第一跖骨 - 内侧楔骨角度。这种病理结构是一个三维结构,它包含了第一跖骨的关节形态、三平面骨定位以及软组织失衡。或许,三维计算机断层扫描成像将能更好地洞察这一结构。