Nangia Sushma, Pal Mansi M, Saili Arvind, Gupta Usha
Department of Pediatrics, Kalawati Saran Children Hospital & Lady Hardinge Medical College, New Delhi, India.
Department of Pediatrics, Kalawati Saran Children Hospital & Lady Hardinge Medical College, New Delhi, India.
Resuscitation. 2015 Dec;97:83-7. doi: 10.1016/j.resuscitation.2015.09.394. Epub 2015 Oct 11.
Evidence about IP-OP suction and selective tracheal intubation in meconium stained neonates is from developed countries. Little information is available about their role in developing countries with high incidence of meconium staining and MAS. This randomized trial was planned to evaluate the effectiveness of IP-OP suction in meconium stained term neonates on prevention of MAS and reduction of its severity.
Out of 540 meconium stained full term, cephalic presentation, singleton neonates without major congenital malformations born from June'08 to January'09, 31 were excluded and 509 randomized. In the intervention group IP-OP suction was done at the time of delivery of head using a 10 Fr suction catheter with a negative pressure of 100 mmHg. No IP-OP suction was performed in control group. All neonates with MSAF were assessed as vigorous or non-vigorous after birth and provided care as per NRP guidelines 2005.
Two hundred and fifty three neonates were randomized to IP-OP suction and 256 to no IP-OP suction. Eighty-two neonates (16%) developed MAS, the primary outcome parameter, with 40 infants in the intervention group (15.8%) and 42 (16.4%) in the non-intervention group (RR 0.86, 95% CI 0.60-1.54). Incidence of severe MAS was comparable (3.55% vs. 2.34%) (P value=0.40). Other variables like requirement of oxygen >48 h (9.8% vs. 10.5%) and mortality (2.7% vs. 1.7%) were also comparable.
IP-OP suctioning did not reduce the incidence or severity of MAS even in a setting of high incidence of MAS in a developing country. The mortality in two groups was comparable.
关于胎粪污染新生儿的口咽气道吸引术(IP-OP)和选择性气管插管的证据来自发达国家。对于在胎粪污染和胎粪吸入综合征(MAS)高发的发展中国家,它们所起的作用了解甚少。本随机试验旨在评估口咽气道吸引术对足月胎粪污染新生儿预防胎粪吸入综合征及减轻其严重程度的有效性。
在2008年6月至2009年1月出生的540例足月、头先露、单胎、无重大先天性畸形的胎粪污染新生儿中,排除31例,509例随机分组。干预组在胎头娩出时使用10 Fr吸引导管,以100 mmHg负压进行口咽气道吸引。对照组不进行口咽气道吸引。所有羊水胎粪污染的新生儿出生后评估为活力好或活力差,并按照2005年新生儿复苏项目(NRP)指南进行护理。
253例新生儿随机接受口咽气道吸引,256例未接受。82例新生儿(16%)发生了主要结局指标胎粪吸入综合征,干预组40例(15.8%),非干预组42例(16.4%)(相对危险度0.86,95%可信区间0.60 - 1.54)。严重胎粪吸入综合征的发生率相当(3.55%对2.34%)(P值 = 0.40)。其他变量如吸氧超过48小时(9.8%对10.5%)和死亡率(2.7%对1.7%)也相当。
即使在一个胎粪吸入综合征高发的发展中国家环境中,口咽气道吸引术也未降低胎粪吸入综合征的发生率或严重程度。两组的死亡率相当。