Westman Mark E, Malik Richard, Hall Evelyn, Sheehy Paul A, Norris Jacqueline M
Faculty of Veterinary Science, The University of Sydney, NSW 2006, Australia.
Centre for Veterinary Education, The University of Sydney, NSW 2006, Australia.
Comp Immunol Microbiol Infect Dis. 2015 Oct;42:43-52. doi: 10.1016/j.cimid.2015.07.004. Epub 2015 Aug 6.
This study challenges the commonly held view that the feline immunodeficiency virus (FIV) infection status of FIV-vaccinated cats cannot be determined using point-of-care antibody test kits due to indistinguishable antibody production in FIV-vaccinated and naturally FIV-infected cats. The performance of three commercially available point-of-care antibody test kits was compared in a mixed population of FIV-vaccinated (n=119) and FIV-unvaccinated (n=239) cats in Australia. FIV infection status was assigned by considering the results of all antibody kits in concert with results from a commercially available PCR assay (FIV RealPCR™). Two lateral flow immunochromatography test kits (Witness FeLV/FIV; Anigen Rapid FIV/FeLV) had excellent overall sensitivity (100%; 100%) and specificity (98%; 100%) and could discern the true FIV infection status of cats, irrespective of FIV vaccination history. The lateral flow ELISA test kit (SNAP FIV/FeLV Combo) could not determine if antibodies detected were due to previous FIV vaccination, natural FIV infection, or both. The sensitivity and specificity of FIV RealPCR™ for detection of viral and proviral nucleic acid was 92% and 99%, respectively. These results will potentially change the way veterinary practitioners screen for FIV in jurisdictions where FIV vaccination is practiced, especially in shelter scenarios where the feasibility of mass screening is impacted by the cost of testing.
本研究对一种普遍观点提出了挑战,该观点认为,由于接种猫免疫缺陷病毒(FIV)疫苗的猫和自然感染FIV的猫产生的抗体无法区分,因此无法使用即时护理抗体检测试剂盒来确定接种FIV疫苗的猫的FIV感染状态。在澳大利亚,对119只接种FIV疫苗的猫和239只未接种FIV疫苗的猫的混合群体,比较了三种市售即时护理抗体检测试剂盒的性能。通过综合考虑所有抗体试剂盒的结果以及一种市售PCR检测(FIV RealPCR™)的结果来确定FIV感染状态。两种侧向流动免疫层析检测试剂盒(Witness FeLV/FIV;Anigen Rapid FIV/FeLV)具有出色的总体敏感性(均为100%)和特异性(分别为98%和100%),并且能够辨别猫的真实FIV感染状态,而不论其FIV疫苗接种史如何。侧向流动ELISA检测试剂盒(SNAP FIV/FeLV Combo)无法确定检测到的抗体是由于先前接种FIV疫苗、自然感染FIV还是两者皆有。FIV RealPCR™检测病毒和前病毒核酸的敏感性和特异性分别为92%和99%。这些结果可能会改变兽医从业人员在实施FIV疫苗接种的辖区筛查FIV的方式,特别是在收容所环境中,大规模筛查的可行性会受到检测成本的影响。