Chowdhury Ahmed I A, Krol Magdalena M, Kocur Christopher M, Boparai Hardiljeet K, Weber Kela P, Sleep Brent E, O'Carroll Denis M
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, The University of Western Ontario, 1151 Richmond Street, London, ON N6A 5B9, Canada.
Department of Civil Engineering, Lassonde School of Engineering, York University, 4700 Keele St., Toronto, ON M3J 1P3, Canada.
J Contam Hydrol. 2015 Dec;183:16-28. doi: 10.1016/j.jconhyd.2015.10.003. Epub 2015 Oct 9.
Nano-scale zero valent iron (nZVI) has been used at a number of contaminated sites over the last decade. At most of these sites, significant decreases in contaminant concentrations have resulted from the application of nZVI. However, limited work has been completed investigating nZVI field-scale mobility. In this study, a field test was combined with numerical modeling to examine nZVI reactivity along with transport properties in variably saturated soils. The field test consisted of 142L of carboxymethyle cellulose (CMC) stabilized monometallic nZVI synthesized onsite and injected into a variably saturated zone. Periodic groundwater samples were collected from the injection well, as well as, from two monitoring wells to analyze for chlorinated solvents and other geochemistry indicators. This study showed that CMC stabilized monometallic nZVI was able to decrease tricholorethene (TCE) concentrations in groundwater by more than 99% from the historical TCE concentrations. A three dimensional, three phase, finite difference numerical simulator, (CompSim) was used to further investigate nZVI and polymer transport at the variably saturated site. The model was able to accurately predict the field observed head data without parameter fitting. In addition, the numerical simulator estimated the mass of nZVI delivered to the saturated and unsaturated zones and distinguished the nZVI phase (i.e. aqueous or attached). The simulation results showed that the injected slurry migrated radially outward from the injection well, and therefore nZVI transport was governed by injection velocity and viscosity of the injected solution. A suite of sensitivity analyses was performed to investigate the impact of different injection scenarios (e.g. different volume and injection rate) on nZVI migration. Simulation results showed that injection of a higher nZVI volume delivered more iron particles at a given distance; however, the travel distance was not proportional to the increase in volume. Moreover, simulation results showed that using a 1D transport equation to simulate nZVI migration in the subsurface may overestimate the travel distance. This is because the 1D transport equation assumes a constant velocity while pore water velocity radially decreases from the well during injection. This study suggests that on-site synthesized nZVI particles are mobile in the subsurface and that a numerical simulator can be a valuable tool for optimal design of nZVI field applications.
在过去十年中,纳米级零价铁(nZVI)已在多个受污染场地得到应用。在这些场地中的大多数,由于应用nZVI,污染物浓度显著降低。然而,关于nZVI在现场尺度下迁移性的研究工作有限。在本研究中,将现场试验与数值模拟相结合,以研究nZVI在变饱和土壤中的反应性及传输特性。现场试验包括142升羧甲基纤维素(CMC)稳定的单金属nZVI,该nZVI在现场合成并注入到一个变饱和区域。定期从注入井以及两口监测井采集地下水样本,以分析氯代溶剂和其他地球化学指标。本研究表明,CMC稳定的单金属nZVI能够使地下水中的三氯乙烯(TCE)浓度比历史TCE浓度降低99%以上。使用三维、三相有限差分数值模拟器(CompSim)进一步研究nZVI和聚合物在变饱和场地中的传输。该模型能够在不进行参数拟合的情况下准确预测现场观测到的水头数据。此外,数值模拟器估计了输送到饱和区和非饱和区的nZVI质量,并区分了nZVI相(即水溶态或附着态)。模拟结果表明,注入的浆液从注入井径向向外迁移,因此nZVI的传输受注入速度和注入溶液粘度的控制。进行了一系列敏感性分析,以研究不同注入方案(如不同体积和注入速率)对nZVI迁移的影响。模拟结果表明,在给定距离处,注入较高体积的nZVI会输送更多的铁颗粒;然而,传播距离与体积增加不成正比。此外,模拟结果表明,使用一维输运方程来模拟nZVI在地下的迁移可能会高估传播距离。这是因为一维输运方程假设速度恒定,而在注入过程中孔隙水速度从井径向向外降低。本研究表明,现场合成的nZVI颗粒在地下是可移动的,并且数值模拟器对于nZVI现场应用的优化设计可能是一个有价值的工具。