Crump William J, Fricker R Steven
a University of Louisville School of Medicine Trover Campus at Baptist Health Madisonville , Madisonville , Kentucky , USA.
Teach Learn Med. 2015;27(4):422-30. doi: 10.1080/10401334.2015.1077709.
Rural medical students who attend urban medical schools experience urban disruption that may make it less likely that they will return to rural practice. Most prematriculation programs focus on academic preparation and are in urban areas, potentially adding to urban disruption. Most initial learning experiences concerning communication with patients are also in urban areas.
Fifty-nine rural preclinical students completed a 3-week summer rural prematriculation program from 2009 to 2014. The focus was on learning a holistic approach to interviewing patients and experiential learning based in a rural practice. Group reflection sessions focused on understanding health beliefs, psychosocial details of the patient's life, and the importance of the sense of place. Measures included student reports, program evaluations, and a pre- and post- 10-item opinion survey focused on the students' perceived importance of traditional biomedical and psychosocial knowledge.
The program was based at the Trover Campus, a regional clinical campus of the University of Louisville School of Medicine, in a town of 20,000 in the western Kentucky coalfields that is 150 miles from the main urban campus. Practice site assignments were in surrounding medically underserved towns in family medicine practices.
After the 3-week experience, students became comfortable with interviews concerning health habits using the Prochaska model of lifestyle modification and expressed an increased importance of some psychosocial factors and a corresponding decrease in importance of traditional biomedical factors in choosing treatment for an individual patient (significant results by Mann-Whitney, two-tailed, ranged U = 1136.0, p = .001 to U = 1377.5, p ≤ .05). Student reports showed that the students gained a new detailed understanding of rural practice. Students also expressed an appreciation for having developed a support network of fellow rural students with whom they would begin medical school on the urban campus.
These results support the value of a summer prematriculation program for rural students based in a rural area. New appreciation for psychosocial patient factors, new skills in communication with patients, new understanding of the details of rural practice, and new relationships with other rural classmates were perceived as positive aspects of the program. Longer term measures of whether the program decreased urban disruption significantly will require continued tracking of the students until they make a practice choice 7 to 9 years later. Wider collaboration with other medical school rural programs is necessary to determine which aspects of rural-focused training are most effective.
在城市医学院就读的农村医学生面临城市环境带来的困扰,这可能降低他们回到农村行医的可能性。大多数预科项目专注于学术准备,且位于城市地区,这可能加剧城市环境带来的困扰。大多数关于与患者沟通的初始学习体验也在城市地区。
2009年至2014年,59名农村临床前学生参加了为期3周的夏季农村预科项目。重点是学习整体的患者访谈方法以及基于农村实践的体验式学习。小组反思会议聚焦于理解健康观念、患者生活的心理社会细节以及场所感的重要性。测量方法包括学生报告、项目评估,以及一项前后各10项的意见调查,该调查聚焦于学生对传统生物医学知识和心理社会知识重要性的认知。
该项目以特罗弗校区为基地,特罗弗校区是路易斯维尔大学医学院的一个地区临床校区,位于肯塔基州西部煤田一个有2万人口的城镇,距离主要城市校区150英里。实习地点安排在周边医疗服务不足城镇的家庭医学诊所。
经过为期3周的体验后,学生们能够自如地运用普罗查斯卡生活方式改变模型进行有关健康习惯的访谈,并表示在为个体患者选择治疗方案时,一些心理社会因素的重要性增加,而传统生物医学因素的重要性相应降低(曼-惠特尼双尾检验结果显著,U值范围为1136.0,p = 0.001至1377.5,p≤0.05)。学生报告显示,学生们对农村医疗实践有了新的详细了解。学生们还表示,很高兴与其他农村学生建立了支持网络,他们将在城市校区一起开始医学院的学习。
这些结果支持了以农村地区为基地的农村学生夏季预科项目的价值。对患者心理社会因素的新认识、与患者沟通的新技能、对农村医疗实践细节的新理解以及与其他农村同学的新关系被视为该项目的积极方面。要确定该项目是否能显著减少城市环境带来的困扰,需要对学生进行长期跟踪,直到他们在7至9年后做出职业选择。有必要与其他医学院的农村项目进行更广泛的合作,以确定农村重点培训的哪些方面最有效。