Ebner H, Neuchrist C, Havelec L, Kraft D
Ambulatorium für Allegie und klinische Immunologie, Wien.
Wien Klin Wochenschr. 1989 Aug 4;101(15):504-11.
In a prospective study, 60 patients with allergic rhinoconjunctivitis and/or asthma due to house dust mites were chosen for hyposensitization treatment with Migen (M) or Pharmalgen (P). Immunotherapy stretched over a whole year and every 3 months clinical results were evaluated by the patient's symptom score, by results of skin prick and conjunctival provocation tests, as well as by RIA and ELISA regarding the total and specific IgE and also specific IgG and IgG4 levels. Out of 30 patients of the M group, 15 were followed up over the whole therapeutic regimen, 4 of whom showed a very good, 7 a good to moderate clinical outcome and 4 showed no improvement at all. In the P group, 17 out of 30 patients were followed up whereby 9 showed a very good and 8 a good to moderate response. In both groups of patients a statistically significant decrease in skin and conjunctival sensitivity to mite allergens was observed after 12 months of therapy. However, there was no correlation between this observation and the failure or success of immunotherapy. Furthermore, in both groups there was significant increase in total and specific IgE (with a slight decrease after 6 to 12 months) and also in specific IgG and IgG4 (especially in the P group), but again these changes in antibody levels gave no indication of a good or bad clinical outcome. Hence, we believe other reasons than the usually presented thesis of inducing "blocking antibodies" by immunotherapy to be responsible for the well-known effects of hyposensitization.
在一项前瞻性研究中,选取了60例因屋尘螨导致过敏性鼻结膜炎和/或哮喘的患者,用Migen(M)或Pharmalgen(P)进行脱敏治疗。免疫治疗持续一整年,每3个月通过患者症状评分、皮肤点刺试验和结膜激发试验结果,以及通过放射免疫分析(RIA)和酶联免疫吸附测定(ELISA)检测总IgE和特异性IgE以及特异性IgG和IgG4水平来评估临床结果。M组的30例患者中,有15例在整个治疗方案期间接受了随访,其中4例显示效果非常好,7例显示效果良好至中等,4例则完全没有改善。在P组的30例患者中,有17例接受了随访,其中9例显示效果非常好,8例显示效果良好至中等。在两组患者中,治疗12个月后均观察到皮肤和结膜对螨过敏原的敏感性在统计学上显著降低。然而,这一观察结果与免疫治疗的失败或成功并无关联。此外,两组患者的总IgE和特异性IgE均显著升高(6至12个月后略有下降),特异性IgG和IgG4也显著升高(尤其是在P组),但同样,这些抗体水平的变化并未表明临床结果的好坏。因此,我们认为,除了通常提出的免疫治疗诱导“封闭抗体”这一论点外,其他原因才是脱敏治疗产生众所周知效果的原因。