Moura Ed Carlos Rey, de Oliveira Honda Claudio A, Bringel Roberto Cesar Teixeira, Leal Plinio da Cunha, Filho Gasper de Jesus Lopes, Sakata Rioko Kinmiko
Dept. of Anesthesia, Universidade Federal de São Paulo, Brazil.
Pain Physician. 2016 Jan;19(1):E79-86.
BACKGROUND: Adequate analgesia is important for early hospital discharge after meniscectomy. A femoral nerve block may reduce the need for systemic analgesics, with fewer side effects; however, motor block can occur. Ultrasound-guided femoral nerve block may reduce the required local anesthetic concentration, preventing motor block. OBJECTIVE: The primary objective of this study was to determine the lowest effective analgesic concentration of bupivacaine in 50% (EC50) and in 90% (EC90) of patients for a successful ultrasound-guided femoral nerve block in arthroscopic knee meniscectomy. STUDY DESIGN: This was a prospective, randomized, double-blind, controlled trial. SETTINGS: This study was conducted at Hospital São Domingos. METHODS: A total of 52 patients undergoing arthroscopic knee meniscectomy were submitted to ultrasound-guided femoral nerve block using 22 mL bupivacaine. The bupivacaine concentration given to a study patient was determined by the response of the previous patient (a biased-coin design up-down sequential method). If the previous patient had a negative response, the bupivacaine concentration was increased by 0.05% for the next case. If the previous patient had a positive response, the next patient was randomized to receive the same bupivacaine concentration (with a probability of 0.89) or to have a decrease by 0.05% (with a probability of 0.11). A successful block was defined by a numerical pain intensity scale score < 4 (0 = no pain; 10 = worst imaginable pain) in 3 different evaluations. If the pain intensity score was = 4 (moderate or severe pain) at any time, the block was considered failed. General anesthesia was induced with 30 µg/kg alfentanil and 2 mg/kg propofol, followed by propofol maintanance, plus remifentanil if needed. Postoperative analgesia supplementation was performed with dipyrone; ketoprofen and tramadol were given if needed. DATA MEASUREMENTS: The following parameters were evaluated: numerical pain intensity score, duration of analgesia, supplementary analgesic dose in 24 hours, and need for intraoperative remifentanil. RESULTS: The EC50 was 0.160 (95% CI: 0.150 - 0.189), and EC90 was 0.271 (95% CI: 0.196 - 0.300). There was no difference in numerical pain intensity score for the different concentrations of bupivacaine. A successful block was achieved in 45 patients, with no difference according to bupivacaine concentration. Time to first analgesic supplementation dose was longer for bupivacaine concentrations = 0.3% (543.8 ± 283.8 min.), compared to 0.25% (391.3 ± 177.8 min.) and < 0.25% (302.3 ± 210.1 min.). There were no differences in supplementary analgesic dose in 24 hours nor in the use of intraoperative remifentanil according to bupivacaine concentration. LIMITATIONS: The analgesic effect was measured only during the first 2 hours. CONCLUSIONS: Bupivacaine EC50 for ultrasound-guided femoral nerve block was 0.160 (95% CI: 0.150 - 0.189), and EC90 was 0.271 (95% CI: 0.196 - 0.300).
背景:半月板切除术后充分镇痛对于早期出院很重要。股神经阻滞可减少全身镇痛药的需求,且副作用较少;然而,可能会出现运动阻滞。超声引导下股神经阻滞可降低所需的局部麻醉药浓度,预防运动阻滞。 目的:本研究的主要目的是确定布比卡因在关节镜下膝关节半月板切除术中成功进行超声引导股神经阻滞时,50%(EC50)和90%(EC90)患者的最低有效镇痛浓度。 研究设计:这是一项前瞻性、随机、双盲、对照试验。 研究地点:本研究在圣多明戈医院进行。 方法:共有52例行关节镜下膝关节半月板切除术的患者接受了使用22 mL布比卡因的超声引导股神经阻滞。给予研究患者的布比卡因浓度由前一位患者的反应确定(一种偏倚硬币设计的上下顺序法)。如果前一位患者反应阴性,则下一例患者的布比卡因浓度增加0.05%。如果前一位患者反应阳性,则下一位患者随机接受相同的布比卡因浓度(概率为0.89)或降低0.05%(概率为0.11)。成功的阻滞定义为在3次不同评估中数字疼痛强度量表评分<4(0 = 无疼痛;10 = 难以想象的剧痛)。如果疼痛强度评分在任何时候=4(中度或重度疼痛),则认为阻滞失败。采用30 µg/kg阿芬太尼和2 mg/kg丙泊酚诱导全身麻醉,随后用丙泊酚维持,必要时加用瑞芬太尼。术后用安乃近补充镇痛;必要时给予酮洛芬和曲马多。 数据测量:评估以下参数:数字疼痛强度评分、镇痛持续时间、24小时补充镇痛剂量以及术中瑞芬太尼的需求。 结果:EC50为0.160(95%CI:0.150 - 0.189),EC90为0.271(95%CI:0.196 - 0.300)。不同浓度布比卡因的数字疼痛强度评分无差异。45例患者实现了成功阻滞,根据布比卡因浓度无差异。布比卡因浓度=0.3%(543.8±283.8分钟)时,首次补充镇痛剂量的时间比0.25%(391.3±177.8分钟)和<0.25%(302.3±210.1分钟)时长。根据布比卡因浓度,24小时补充镇痛剂量以及术中瑞芬太尼的使用无差异。 局限性:仅在最初2小时内测量镇痛效果。 结论:超声引导股神经阻滞的布比卡因EC50为0.160(95%CI:0.150 - 0.189),EC90为0.271(95%CI:0.196 - 0.300)。
Anesthesiol Res Pract. 2018-7-29
North Clin Istanb. 2017-8-25