Schneekloth Brian J, Lowery Nicholas J, Wukich Dane K
Podiatric Medicine and Surgery Residency Program, UPMC Mercy and University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, Pittsburgh PA.
Podiatric Medicine and Surgery Residency Program, UPMC Mercy and University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, Pittsburgh PA; Washington Health System Wound and Skin Healing Center and Hyperbaric Medicine, Washington, PA.
J Foot Ankle Surg. 2016 May-Jun;55(3):586-90. doi: 10.1053/j.jfas.2015.12.001. Epub 2016 Jan 23.
Charcot neuroarthropathy (CN) of the foot and ankle is a demanding clinical dilemma, and surgical management can be very complicated. Historically, the evidence guiding surgical management of CN has been small retrospective case series and expert opinions. The purpose of the present report was to provide a systematic review of studies published from 2009 to 2014 and to review the indications for surgery. A Medline search was performed, and a systematic review of studies discussing the surgical management of CN was undertaken. Thirty reports fit the inclusion criteria for our study, including 860 patients who had undergone a surgical procedure for the treatment of CN. The surgical procedures included amputation, arthrodesis, debridement of ulcers, drainage of infections, and exostectomy. The midfoot was addressed in 26.9% of cases, the hindfoot in 41.6%, and the ankle in 38.4%. Of the 30 studies, 24 were retrospective case series (level 4), 4 were controlled retrospective studies (level 3), and 2 were level II studies. The overall amputation rate was 8.9%. The quality of the published data on the surgical management of CN has improved during the past several years. Evidence concerning the timing of treatment and the use of different fixation methods remains inconclusive.
足踝部夏科氏神经关节病(CN)是一个棘手的临床难题,手术治疗可能非常复杂。从历史上看,指导CN手术治疗的证据一直是小型回顾性病例系列和专家意见。本报告的目的是对2009年至2014年发表的研究进行系统评价,并回顾手术适应症。进行了Medline检索,并对讨论CN手术治疗的研究进行了系统评价。30篇报告符合我们研究的纳入标准,包括860例接受过CN手术治疗的患者。手术方式包括截肢、关节融合、溃疡清创、感染引流和骨赘切除术。26.9%的病例涉及中足,41.6%涉及后足,38.4%涉及踝关节。在这30项研究中,24项是回顾性病例系列(4级),4项是对照回顾性研究(3级),2项是2级研究。总体截肢率为8.9%。在过去几年中,关于CN手术治疗的已发表数据质量有所提高。关于治疗时机和不同固定方法使用的证据仍然不明确。