Ramakrishnan Prabhath, Bahirwani Shraddha, Valambath Smruthi
Department of Oral Medicine and Radiology, Kannur Dental College, Kannur, Kerala, India.
Department of Oral Medicine and Radiology, Dr. Syamala Reddy Dental College Hospital and Research, Marathahalli, India.
J Forensic Dent Sci. 2015 Sep-Dec;7(3):195-200. doi: 10.4103/0975-1475.172434.
The present study was undertaken with the objective of ascertaining whether latent lip prints generated by persistent lipsticks and developed using lysochrome dyes have the potential of use in sex determination and personal identification.
This study included a total of 100 subjects (50 males and 50 females) whose latent lip prints were obtained by applying the persistent lipstick Revlon ColorStay Overtime(®) manufactured by Revlon(®) consumer products corporation, NewYork, USA, and lifting the prints with cellophane sheets. The prints were then developed using lysochrome dyes, and all the samples were blinded and then graded based on defined patterns from the Suzuki and Tsuchihashi classification.
No two lip prints were found to be alike. Type I was found to be the most prevalent type. In the female population, Type I (61%) was most prevalent, followed by Type I' (28%), Type II (9%), Type III (2%), Type IV (1%), and Type V (1%); in the male population, Type I (33%) was most prevalent, followed by Type II (23%), Type III (18%), Type IV (14%), Type I' (10%), and Type V (3%). Two examiners were able to determine the correct sexes from the given sample sizes. Their interobserver agreement was assessed using the kappa coefficient for males (κ =0.870) and females (κ = 0.870). Their accuracy was assessed with a confidence interval (CI) of 91.48-99.38.
Lysochrome dyes are very efficacious in developing latent lip prints. This preliminary study has conclusively proved that latent lip prints developed with lysochrome dyes hold the potential for use in sex determination and can be maintained in a digital database.
本研究旨在确定由持久性口红产生并使用脂色素染料显影的潜在唇纹是否具有用于性别鉴定和个人识别的潜力。
本研究共纳入100名受试者(50名男性和50名女性),其潜在唇纹通过涂抹美国纽约露华浓消费品公司生产的持久性口红露华浓不脱色全天候(®)获得,并用玻璃纸将唇纹印下。然后使用脂色素染料对唇纹进行显影,所有样本均进行盲法处理,随后根据铃木和土桥分类法中的定义模式进行分级。
未发现有两条唇纹完全相同。I型被发现是最常见的类型。在女性群体中,I型(61%)最为常见,其次是I'型(28%)、II型(9%)、III型(2%)、IV型(1%)和V型(1%);在男性群体中,I型(33%)最为常见,其次是II型(23%)、III型(18%)、IV型(14%)、I'型(10%)和V型(3%)。两名检查人员能够从给定的样本量中确定正确的性别。使用卡方系数评估他们在男性(κ = 0.870)和女性(κ = 0.870)中的观察者间一致性。用91.48 - 99.38的置信区间(CI)评估他们的准确性。
脂色素染料在显影潜在唇纹方面非常有效。这项初步研究已确凿证明,用脂色素染料显影的潜在唇纹具有用于性别鉴定的潜力,并且可以保存在数字数据库中。