Lacaine F, Houry S, Huguier M
Rev Prat. 1989 Oct 1;39(22):1962-4.
Survival at 5 years has been observed in 5 to 10 p. 100 of patients with cancer of the exocrine pancreas and lower biliary tract who underwent surgical resection. However, since radical surgery can only be performed in about one out of five patients, 98 p. 100 of patients with pancreatic cancer receive no more than a palliative treatment. Owing to the sombre prognosis of this type of cancer, special efforts are being made to discover new adjuvant treatments that will enhance the effects of curative or, more often, palliative treatments. These adjuvant treatments fall into three categories: chemotherapy, radiotherapy and hormonal therapy. Most trials have been carried out in cancers of the exocrine pancreas. The main criticism that can be raises against trials conducted in patients with cancer of the biliary tract is that none of them comprised an untreated control group, and in the absence of control group it is impossible to determine whether treatment really improved the patients' survival. This does not apply to trials conducted in patients with cancer of the endocrine pancreas: some trials included a control group chosen at random, whilst in other trials therapeutic effectiveness was judged on the "response rate". Yet an objective "response rate", as can be evaluated by such morphological examination as computerized tomography, is not synonymous with "therapeutic effectiveness", as the latter can only be asserted by an increase of survival. The authors described the adjuvant treatments that have been proposed for pancreatic cancer.
接受手术切除的外分泌性胰腺癌和低位胆道癌患者中,5年生存率为5%至10%。然而,由于根治性手术仅能在约五分之一的患者中进行,98%的胰腺癌患者接受的只是姑息治疗。鉴于这类癌症的预后严峻,人们正在做出特别努力以探寻新的辅助治疗方法,从而增强治愈性治疗(更多时候是姑息性治疗)的效果。这些辅助治疗分为三类:化疗、放疗和激素治疗。大多数试验是在外分泌性胰腺癌患者中开展的。针对胆道癌患者所进行的试验,主要可提出的批评意见是,这些试验均未设置未接受治疗的对照组,而在没有对照组的情况下,无法确定治疗是否真的提高了患者的生存率。这不适用于在内分泌性胰腺癌患者中开展的试验:一些试验纳入了随机选择的对照组,而在其他试验中,治疗效果是根据“缓解率”来判断的。然而,像通过计算机断层扫描等形态学检查所评估的客观“缓解率”,并非“治疗效果”的同义词,因为后者只能通过生存率的提高来确定。作者描述了已被提出用于胰腺癌的辅助治疗方法。