Gerard A, Metzger U, Buyse M
Department of Surgery, Institut Jules Bordet, Brussels, Belgium.
Anticancer Res. 1989 Jul-Aug;9(4):1033-5.
While uncontrolled and retrospective studies suggest a treatment benefit for radiotherapy or chemotherapy when administered as adjuvant before or after surgical resection with a curative aim for colon cancer, prospective randomized clinicals trials failed to show any advantage and do not to date confirm the efficiency of the proposed adjuvant therapy. For rectal cancer, preoperative irradiation administered at the dose of 34.5 Gy and postoperative radiotherapy administered at the dose of 46 to 53 Gy markedly decreased the local recurrence rate, however, these treatments failed to improve the 5 year survival rate significantly. Recently the efficacy of a postoperative chemotherapy was observed in a randomized clinical trial. The administration of methyl-CCNU, Vincristine and 5-fluorouracil after surgical resection of rectal cancer improved both the disease-free survival and the survival rate. Another randomized study showed a benefit of combined post-operative radiotherapy and chemotherapy with methyl-CCNU and 5-FU. Advantages and disadvantages of preoperative irradiation treatment and postoperative irradiation treatment are discussed.
虽然非对照和回顾性研究表明,以根治为目的对结肠癌进行手术切除前后给予放疗或化疗作为辅助治疗有一定益处,但前瞻性随机临床试验未能显示出任何优势,且至今尚未证实所提议的辅助治疗的有效性。对于直肠癌,术前给予34.5 Gy剂量的放疗和术后给予46至53 Gy剂量的放疗显著降低了局部复发率,然而,这些治疗未能显著提高5年生存率。最近在一项随机临床试验中观察到术后化疗的疗效。直肠癌手术切除后给予甲基环己亚硝脲、长春新碱和5-氟尿嘧啶可改善无病生存期和生存率。另一项随机研究表明,术后放疗与甲基环己亚硝脲和5-氟尿嘧啶联合化疗有益。文中讨论了术前放疗和术后放疗的优缺点。